I investigate how changing incentives schemes can affect worker effort by manipulating salience. I test the predictions of a salience model in an online experiment, where I vary the salience of different aspects of an incentive scheme, holding constant the objective expected incentives. I test whether by doing so workers can be made to exert more effort relative to the Bayesian benchmark.
Experimental design
Participants on Amazon Mechanical Turk will make a series of binary effort choices, where they can either complete 1 or 6 "tasks". Each task consists of transcribing blurry greek letters. Each option comes with a lottery, where the lottery for 6 tasks weakly dominates the lottery for doing 1 task. Holding the expected benefit of completing extra tasks constant, I vary the riskiness of exerting effort so that the upside of doing so becomes more or less salient.
Design details
Randomization method
I use a timer to implement the lotteries. Respondents get to stop a timer that counts up from zero at a time of their choosing. The last two digits of the timer (which includes milliseconds) are the numbers used to determine their payoffs in the earnings. In piloting, I have found both that respondents are unable to control these last two digits (which appear uniformly distributed as we would expect) and do not appear to believe they can do so (e.g., they do not systematically pick risky lotteries that would be especially attractive if they could control the value of the timer better than they in fact can).
To randomly assign respondents to treatments, I use the randomizer function in Qualtrics.
Randomization unit
Across individuals, I randomize whether p (the parameter described above) is 0.10, 0.50, or 0.90. Within individuals, I randomize the order in which the binary effort choices are presented to them.
Randomization occurs within individual. In particular, each participant sees all twelve combinations of expected incentive strength in a random order. However, to account for correlation across choices within individual, I will cluster my standard errors at the individual level where relevant.
Clusters
I plan to include 400 individuals per treatment arm, or 1,200 overall.
Observations
Each respondent makes 12 effort decisions, so the effective number of observations is 14,400.
Arms
400 people per treatment arm.
Primary outcomes
How often respondents choose to do more tasks rather than fewer.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.