Do Politicians Discriminate Against (polarized) Constituents? A Field Experiment on State Legislators

How to cite

Köhler, Ekkehard; May, Marius. 2020. "Do Politicians Discriminate Against (polarized) Constituents? A Field Experiment on State Legislators." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006599. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6599-1.5

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ekkehard Köhler* , Marius May

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006599
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6599-1.5
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-10-26 – 2021-04-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J15 C93 D72
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6599

Abstract

Experiments are often replicated in discrimination research. These replication studies are a necessary means of checking and confirming effects. With this motivation we want to replicate a study by Butler and Broockman (2011) on discrimination against blacks in the light of the approaching US election campaign.
Butler and Broockmann (2011) investigated the effect of the first and last name of a person who makes a request to “his" or "her" MP. The representatives of the US citizens are known as so-called 'State Legislators'. The 'State Legislators' are current members of the Lower Chamber (State Assembly, House of Representatives etc.) or the Upper Chamber (Senate) of a US state. Following the experimental design of Butler and Broockman (2011), inquiries were made to these 'State Legislators'. The inquiries were sent by two different people with fictitious first and last names, which, according to the US census, are very likely to be “black” or “white”. The request was for information on how to register to vote. With the help of these name signals, politicians can be put in the position of responding to inquiries from different US citizens. If the request is answered, this is an indication of responsiveness. The time it takes to receive a response can also be examined.
Study design
We want to use the same design during the US election campaign. To do this, we use an experimental survey to investigate whether the race of the inquirer has an influence on whether and how quickly the addressees respond to inquiries from these two inquirers. By varying the inquirer, we achieve an experimental character, just as Butler and Broockman (2011) and many other studies from political science have presented: While the name 'Matthew Mueller' can be connected with a white, the name 'Deshawn Jackson 'more likely to be associated with a black. We want to use these names and ask about the prevalence of police violence in each constituency.

Intervention

We ask question

Experimental design

This experiment aims to find effects of taste-based discrimination within US-American politicians in the responsiveness towards blacks and whites as well towards voters of different political attitudes.
Therefore, we designed an experiment with two binary dimensions on side of the inquirers who request information concerning police violence in their election area from their respective state legislator. State legislators belong to the Lower Chamber and the Upper Chamber of each state. The first of the two dimensions of the inquirers is the inquirer’s race, which can be either black or white. The second dimension is the opinion concerning police violence in the respective state of residence, with one attitude being that blacks are subject to police violence significantly more often than whites and the other one being that whites are approximately as often subject to police violence as blacks. Each legislator is contacted via email by one of the four profiles which consist of all convex combinations of the two dimensions. We will then observe whether a state legislator responds to the request and if, how much time was required. Essentially, the statistics and other information potentially provided by the legislator are less important than the answer itself. For secondary outcomes (see above), we will check ourselves what political attitude is supported by empiric data.

Design details

Randomization method
Simple Randomization is done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
individual level based on State and technology
Clusters
5045, which is the number of state legislator positions to be elected again on November 3, 2020.
Observations
5045, which is the number of state legislator positions to be elected again on November 3, 2020.
Arms
Approximately 1261 for each of the 4 possible treatments: (1) Black + Police violence tends to harm blacks more (2) Black + Police violence tends two harm both races equally (3) White + Police violence tends to harm blacks more (4) White + Police violence tends two harm both races equally
Primary outcomes
(i) We expect that the Democrats’ responsiveness towards blacks is higher and that the Republicans’ responsiveness towards whites is higher. (ii) We expect that the Democrats’ responsiveness is increased towards inquirers supporting the hypothesis that blacks are subject to police violence more often. Contrarily, we expect that the Republicans’ responsiveness is increased towards inquirers supporting the hypothesis that whites are about as often as blacks subject to police violence. (iii) We expect that the candidates’ responsiveness is higher in case the candidate’s and the inquirer’s race are the same.
Secondary outcomes
(i) We expect a minor increase in the incumbent’s responsiveness if the crime statistic matches the inquirer’s opinion and the ideological view of the incumbent. For the opponent, there is a respective decrease in responsiveness. (ii) We expect a medium increase in the opponent’s responsiveness if the crime statistic matches the inquirer’s opinion and not the ideological view of the incumbent. For the incumbent, there is a respective decrease in responsiveness. (iii) We expect a major increase in the opponent’s responsiveness if the crime statistic does not match the inquirer’s opinion and neither the ideological view of the incumbent. For the incumbent, there is a respective decrease in responsiveness. (iv) We expect a major increase in the incumbent’s responsiveness if the crime statistic does not match the inquirer’s opinion but the ideological view of the incumbent. For the opponent, there is a respective decrease in responsiveness. This is the opposite case to (iii).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords