Effective Policy Communication: Target vs. Instrument
How to cite
D'Acunto, Francesco; Weber, Michael. 2020. "Effective Policy Communication: Target vs. Instrument." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006597. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6597-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Communication targeting households and firms has become a stand-alone policy tool of many central banks. But which forms of communication, if any, can reach ordinary people and manage their economic expectations effectively? In this large-scale randomized control trial, we provide randomly three groups of a representative population of men in Finland with different forms of communication about the same policies that the European Central Bank (ECB) has implemented in April 2020 to reduce the negative shocks due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The communication about the same policies comes from the same source and medium (the twitter account of the Governor of the Bank of Finland, Dr. Olli Rehn), but one group faces a form of target communication, which only discusses the final objective of the policy without discussing the legal instruments the ECB will use to reach such objective, and another group faces a form of instrument communication, which discusses the technical instruments the ECB uses and which form the policy. A control group of subjects faces a tweet discussing a period of economic crisis in Finnish history without any specific connection to the COVID-19 policies implemented by the ECB. Our trial aims to study the effects of different forms of policy communication on the average consumer as well as the heterogeneity of these effects across dimensions we observe in the data---cognitive abilities as a proxy for sophistication and prior income-change beliefs.
Intervention
We propose a within-subject experimental design with three experimental arms: a control group, in which subjects read a tweet by Dr. Rehn referring to the economic crisis of Finland after the First World War and unrelated to current events and policies; a target-communication group, in which subjects read a tweet that discusses the objectives of the ECB's policies implemented in April 2020 to overcome the negative economic shock due to the COVID-19 crisis; an instrument-communication group, in which subjects read a tweet that discusses the legal instrument and the size of the PEPP program the ECB implemented in April 2020. We elicit subjects' beliefs about their households' income both before and after the experimental treatments are administered. To reduce the concern of demand effects, we elicit point estimates in the first instance and full probability distributions ("Manski question") after the treatment.
Experimental design
The design is a within-subject experimental design with 3 experimental arms: a control group, a treatment-communication group, and an instrument-communication group. We do not randomize or stratify any other dimensions.
The manipulation consists of showing subjects a tweet from Dr. Olli Rehn's twitter account that discusses a situation of economic crisis in the history of Finland (control group), the objectives of the ECB policies implemented to overcome the COVID-19-induced economic crisis, and the instruments (PEPP) implemented by the ECB to overcome the COVID-19-induced economic crisis. All tweets are true tweets from the official account of Dr. Rehn.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.