Information and user choice in primary health care markets
How to cite
Kjellsson, Gustav; Ellegård, Lina; Anell, Anders; Dietrichson, Jens. 2015. "Information and user choice in primary health care markets." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000659. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.659-4.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In order to increase quality of care, all regions in Sweden have during the last decade implemented systems where users can choose their primary health care provider, and where there is freedom of establishment for providers. All primary health care units are financed by public means and pre-set user fees, but may be privately or publicly run. For user choice systems to improve the functioning of health care, users must choose health care units that deliver care of relatively high-quality. Previous studies indicate that a very large share of users in Sweden do not compare the quality of providers before making their choice of provider. The transaction costs related to information retrieval and switching present a possible obstacle to the functioning of this market: the gathering of information about and comparison of providers is costly in terms of time, and there are also (small) process costs related to notifying providers of the change. In this study, we provide three randomly drawn samples of the population in the region of Skåne with information about the quality of primary care providers, to see whether this freely available information affects their propensity to change provider, and the type of provider they choose. The first sample is representative of the whole population in the region (above 18 years of age), the second consists of individuals that have recently moved to the region, and the third sample consists of families that are expecting children. We also examine if lowering the process costs on top of providing free information affects the choice frequency, and whether the effects differ for groups defined by for example socioeconomic background and health status.
Intervention
There are three parts to the experiments:
Part 1: In this part, the regional health authority in the region of Skåne (located in the south-west of Sweden) - Region Skåne - provides 1 percent of the population that are over 18 years old with information about the primary care center that they are listed at and its three geographically nearest competitors. The information is sent by mail, and contains information about, among other things, opening hours, quality ratings, and special competences. Within the 1 percent group, there are two treatments: one group receives only information about primary care centers (T1), the other receives this information along with a pre-paid form that notifies the new and old provider about the change (T2).
Part 2: The procedure for this part is similar to the one described for Part 1, it is basically only the target group that differs. In Part 2, information will be sent specifically to individuals who have recently moved to Skåne. There may be such individuals also in the sample for Part 1, but they are a very small subset.
Experimental design
The premise for Part 1 is that the regional health authority has to treat all primary care centers equally, in order to be neutral in terms of competition on this market. Using the random number generator within Stata (which we use for all randomizations), we therefore first draw 11 percent of listed individuals over 18 from each of the 150 primary care centers. Then, we randomly select 9.0909091 percent of these 11 percent, which constitute the treatment group. In total, this procedure implies that 1 percent of the total population over 18 will be treated. The remaining 10 percent constitutes the control group. Among the treatment group, we then randomly assign 25 percent to the group that only receives information (T1), and 75 percent to the group that receives information and a pre-paid change form (T2).
In Part 2, we randomly select 6906 individuals (6059 clusters based on residential address) into treatment and control. The treated group recieves the same information and a pre-paid change form.
Several details about how we will conduct the randomization for Part 3 are presently not known. For administrative reasons Part 3 is postponed.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Anell, A., Dietrichson, J., Ellegård, L. M. & Kjellsson, G. (2021). Information, switching costs, and consumer choice: Evidence from two randomized field experiments in Swedish primary health care. Journal of Public Economics, 196, 104390 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpubeco.2021.104390
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.