Training Entrepreneurs to Act like Scientists: A Field Experiment with Start-ups in Turin

How to cite

Spina, Chiara; Gambardella, Alfonso; Camuffo, Arnaldo; Paolucci, Emilio; Battaglia, Daniele; Colombelli, Alessandra; Raguseo, Elisabetta. 2020. "Training Entrepreneurs to Act like Scientists: A Field Experiment with Start-ups in Turin." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006579. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6579-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Chiara Spina* , Alfonso Gambardella , Arnaldo Camuffo , Emilio Paolucci , Daniele Battaglia , Alessandra Colombelli , Elisabetta Raguseo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006579
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6579-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-07-01 – 2019-02-28
Countries
Italy (Piedmont)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6579

Abstract

This project studies how a scientific approach to entrepreneurial decision-making impacts start-up performance of entrepreneurs with a background in science. We argue that entrepreneurs with a background in science apply more effectively the scientific approach in a business context, since they can exploit their prior knowledge of the scientific method that they learnt in the context of natural sciences. More specifically, we expect that entrepreneurs with a background in science who learn about the scientific approach: (i) exit more, (ii) pivot more and (iii) earn more revenue than other entrepreneurs. To test our predictions, we embed a field experiment into a pre-accelerator program and use this setting to randomly assign entrepreneurial teams to either learn about a scientific approach or not.

Intervention

In order to replicate previous work exploring the relationships between the scientific approach to decision-making and entrepreneurial performance, we replicate the experimental settings presented in Camuffo et al. (2019) and Camuffo et al. (2020). Accordingly, we embed a field experiment in a pre-accelerator program by randomly assigning entrepreneurs to either a treatment (being taught how to use a scientific approach when developing a business idea) or a control group (being taught how to develop a business idea).
This pre-accelerator program provides training to early-stage entrepreneurs for a short period of time (three months). Consistently with previous studies, we targeted early-stage entrepreneurs. After a call for application, that resulted in a total of 149 applications, we selected 142 start-ups. Through STATA, each start-up was randomly assigned to either a treatment or a control group through simple randomization. We checked that treatment (71 start-ups) and control groups (71 start-ups) were balanced on several key covariates that might affect the absorption of the treatment and subsequent outcomes. Differences between treatment and control are small in magnitude, and there are no significant differences between the two groups.
Treated and control teams have been trained during eight sessions from October 2018 to February 2019 (24 hours of training for each group). Consistently with the training supplied by Camuffo et al. (2019), our pre-accelerator program focused on market validation, a series of activities aimed at testing the desirability of a product or service concept against a potential target market. The content and length of each session was the same for both groups, but start-ups in the treatment group were taught how to make entrepreneurial decisions according to the scientific approach. In each class of the treatment group, start-ups were taught to elaborate a theory behind their choices, articulate hypotheses and test them rigorously. The control group, instead, did not learn about the scientific approach, but followed the traditional approach to decision-making used by entrepreneurs, that relies on trial-and-error techniques. We avoid contamination and other threats to internal validity following the same approach used by Camuffo et al. (2019).

Experimental design

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
In order to replicate previous work exploring the relationships between the scientific approach to decision-making and entrepreneurial performance, we replicate the experimental settings presented in Camuffo et al. (2019) and Camuffo et al. (2020). Accordingly, we embed a field experiment in a pre-accelerator program by randomly assigning entrepreneurs to either a treatment (being taught how to use a scientific approach when developing a business idea) or a control group (being taught how to develop a business idea).
This pre-accelerator program provides training to early-stage entrepreneurs for a short period of time (three months). Consistently with previous studies, we targeted early-stage entrepreneurs. After a call for application, that resulted in a total of 149 applications, we selected 142 start-ups. Through STATA, each start-up was randomly assigned to either a treatment or a control group through simple randomization. We checked that treatment (71 start-ups) and control groups (71 start-ups) were balanced on several key covariates that might affect the absorption of the treatment and subsequent outcomes. Differences between treatment and control are small in magnitude, and there are no significant differences between the two groups.
Treated and control teams have been trained during eight sessions from October 2018 to February 2019 (24 hours of training for each group). Consistently with the training supplied by Camuffo et al. (2019), our pre-accelerator program focused on market validation, a series of activities aimed at testing the desirability of a product or service concept against a potential target market. The content and length of each session was the same for both groups, but start-ups in the treatment group were taught how to make entrepreneurial decisions according to the scientific approach. In each class of the treatment group, start-ups were taught to elaborate a theory behind their choices, articulate hypotheses and test them rigorously. The control group, instead, did not learn about the scientific approach, but followed the traditional approach to decision-making used by entrepreneurs, that relies on trial-and-error techniques. We avoid contamination and other threats to internal validity following the same approach used by Camuffo et al. (2019).
Data Collection procedure
Consistently with previous studies, we collected detailed information on all the entrepreneurs using telephone interviews. Consistently with Camuffo et al. (2019), we conducted regular telephone interviews with each start-up. Each Telephone interview usually lasted for about 30 minutes and included questions on changes in the entrepreneurial team, about the activities conducted and on performance. Through these calls, we are able to measure if entrepreneurs abandon their business idea or if they pivot to a different one. We conducted telephone interviews from the end of the training up to February 2020 (17 data collection points, one more data collection point is scheduled for March 2020) on all the 132 start-ups that completed the pre-accelerator program.

Design details

Randomization method
Simple randomization implemented with STATA
Randomization unit
Firm
Clusters
NA
Observations
132 X 18 = 2376
Arms
66 firms in the treatment group, 66 firms in the control group
Primary outcomes
Dependent Variables Exit This is a binary variable equal to 0 until entrepreneurs exit (they abandon the program and cease their start-up), 1 when entrepreneurs decide to exit. Pivot: This is the cumulative number of times in which a start-up changed one of the key elements of their business model canvas. Revenue: Amount of revenue earned by the start-up.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords