Why are firms slow to adopt profitable business practices? Evidence on the roles of present bias, forgetfulness, and overconfidence about memory

How to cite

Higgins, Sean; Ojeda, Waldo; Malmendier, Ulrike; Gertler, Paul. 2020. "Why are firms slow to adopt profitable business practices? Evidence on the roles of present bias, forgetfulness, and overconfidence about memory." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006540. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6540-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sean Higgins* , Waldo Ojeda , Ulrike Malmendier , Paul Gertler

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006540
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6540-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2020-09-29 – 2021-04-01
Countries
Mexico ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6540

Abstract

Why are micro, small, and medium enterprises slow to adopt profitable business practices? We test the role of three behavioral biases: present bias, limited memory, and overconfidence about memory. In partnership with a payments financial technology (FinTech) provider in Mexico, we randomly offer businesses that are already users of the payments technology the opportunity to be charged a lower merchant fee for each payment they receive. We randomly vary whether the firms face a deadline to register for this lower fee, whether they receive a reminder, and whether the reminder is anticipated (i.e., whether we tell them in advance that they will receive a reminder on a certain date).

Intervention

We randomly offer a cost-saving measure to firms who are already users of a financial technology (FinTech) to process electronic payments by debit and credit card: through the FinTech company that processes their payments, we offer to lower the merchant fee they are charged for each sale they make through the technology. This fee reduction intervention is offered through an email and SMS campaign, where firms can complete a short form to obtain the fee reduction. Firms are further randomized into groups that obtain different versions of the emails and SMS messages with some combination of a one-week deadline, one-day deadline, or no deadline, and an anticipated reminder, unanticipated reminder, or no reminder. The firms that assigned to an anticipated or unanticipated reminder group will receive a follow-up reminder email the day before the deadline. Each of the emails will be complemented by two SMS text messages that contain similar information in a condensed format.

Experimental design

Messages with deadlines will either have a one-day deadline or a one-week deadline. For the one-day deadline, they will state that the link must be clicked and form completed “with a deadline of today September 29.” For the one-week deadline, they will state that the form must be completed “with a deadline of October 6.” Messages with a reminder will receive a reminder on October 5; in the groups with both a deadline and reminder, the reminder will also remind the user of the deadline. Messages with an unanticipated reminder will receive a reminder to activate the lower fee on October 5. Messages with an anticipated reminder will receive a reminder to access the link one week after and will also be told in the initial email and SMS message that they will receive a reminder on October 5 if they have not yet activated the lower fee.

As a result, we will have 15 treatment arms:
1) Control, no messages
1. Control, no messages.
2. Messages with no deadline, no reminder, 3.00% offer.
3. Messages with no deadline, anticipated reminder, 3.00% offer.
4. Messages with no deadline, unanticipated reminder, 3.00% offer.
5. Messages with one-week deadline, no reminder, 3.00% offer.
6. Messages with one-week deadline, anticipated reminder, 3.00% offer.
7. Messages with one-week deadline, unanticipated reminder, 3.00% offer.
8. Messages with one-day deadline, no reminder, 3.00% offer.
9. Messages with no deadline, no reminder, 2.75% offer.
10. Messages with no deadline, anticipated reminder, 2.75% offer.
11. Messages with no deadline, unanticipated reminder, 2.75% offer.
12. Messages with one-week deadline, no reminder, 2.75% offer.
13. Messages with one-week deadline, anticipated reminder, 2.75% offer.
14. Messages with one-week deadline, unanticipated reminder, 2.75% offer.
15. Messages with one-day deadline, no reminder, 2.75% offer.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was conducted using the R programming language to assign firms to one of the fifteen treatment arms. No rerandomization was conducted to ensure balance. While no rerandomization was conducted to ensure balance, we did test balance on the variables that we stratified on (business type and baseline sales quartiles) as well as other baseline variables we could measure in the administrative data (tax status of firm, gender of merchant, above/below median time with the technology).
Randomization unit
The randomization unit is the firm level and we use stratified randomization. We use two variables in our stratification. In particular, we stratify based on baseline sales quartiles, which are defined by the average monthly sales from July 2019 to August 2020 (or from the month in which the firm entered the data to August 2020 if it entered the data later than July 2019). We also stratify based on business type, which includes 6 categories: Beauty, Clothing, Professionals, Restaurants, Small Retailers and Other. In total we have 21 cells, because some of the interaction cells between business type and baseline sales quartile were empty. For example, among the “Beauty” business types, every firm was in the 3rd or 4th quartile of baseline sales, so the “Beauty” x 1st quartile and “Beauty” x 2nd quartile strata were empty.
Clusters
34,010 firms
Observations
34,010 firms
Arms
1. Control (no messages): 4010. 2. No deadline, no reminder with 3.00% offer: 2230. 3. No deadline, anticipated reminder with 3.00% offer: 1838. 4. No deadline, unanticipated reminder with 3.00% offer: 2227. 5. One-week deadline, no reminder with 3.00% offer: 2311. 6. One-week deadline, anticipated reminder with 3.00% offer: 1755. 7. One-week deadline, unanticipated reminder with 3.00% offer: 2316. 8. One-day deadline, no reminder with 3.00% offer: 2324. 9. No deadline, no reminder with 2.75% offer: 2230. 10. No deadline, anticipated reminder with 2.75% offer: 1838. 11. No deadline, unanticipated reminder with 2.75% offer: 2229. 12. One-week deadline, no reminder with 2.75% offer: 2311. 13. One-week deadline, anticipated reminder with 2.75% offer: 1753. 14. One-week deadline, unanticipated reminder with 2.75% offer: 2316. 15. One-day deadline, no reminder with 2.75% offer: 2322. Sampling frame: The FinTech company has two types of rates: a fixed rate that is independent of the amount of monthly sales made by the firm, and a “smart rate” that is fixed if the firm makes up to 20,000 pesos in sales in a particular month, and begins decreasing if they make over 20,000 pesos in sales. To define our sampling frame we identified firms in a certain range of monthly sales. Specifically, we set a maximum of monthly sales at 20,000 pesos for firms that had the smart rate (since their status quo rate begins to fall if they have higher sales), and no maximum for firms that had the fixed rate. For the minimum, we are informed by a randomized pilot we did with 11,755 firms in May 2019 where we offered a smaller fee reduction from 3.75% to 3.50%. In that pilot, we found that the take-up rate of the lower fee was increasing in baseline sales, and that the elasticity of sales through the technology with respect to the fee (which is what our partner is interested in, as offering a lower fee may or may not be profitable depending on the elasticity) was statistically significant only for the fourth quartile in baseline sales. Thus, we use the 75th percentile of baseline monthly sales from firms in that randomized pilot (i.e., the minimum sales among firms in the fourth quartile) as the minimum. As a result, our sampling frame for this experiment consists of all firms who are users of this FinTech that had (i) fixed rate and August 2020 sales greater than 1400 pesos with no maximum or (ii) smart rate and August 2020 sales greater than 1400 pesos and less than 20,000 pesos. The sampling frame was made up of 34,010 users. Randomization: among these 34,010 firms, 4,010 firms were randomly assigned to the pure control group that receives no offer; the size of this arm was based on the FinTech company’s desire to cap the number of firms receiving an offer at 30,000. The remaining 30,000 firms were assigned to one of the fourteen other groups. The firms were first randomly assigned to one of seven groups combining deadlines and reminders: (i) no deadline, no reminder; (ii) no deadline, anticipated reminder; (iii) no deadline, unanticipated reminder; (iv) one-week deadline, no reminder; (v) one-week deadline, anticipated reminder; (vi) one-week deadline, unanticipated reminder; (vii) one-day deadline, no reminder. The sample size in each of these seven groups receiving an offer was determined based on power calculations using the results from our May 2019 randomized pilot, as we describe in more detail below. As described above, this randomization is stratified on business type and business sales quartiles. Then among firms assigned to one of these 7 groups receiving an offer, we cross-randomize the rate they are offered, either 3.00% or 2.75%; this cross-randomization is stratified based on initial group assignment, as well as business type and baseline sales quartiles. This leaves us with 15 total treatment arms.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome is a dummy variable that indicates whether a firm took up the lower merchant fee. We will also use this outcome to estimate the model in Ericson (2017) to quantify the relative importance and interaction of different behavioral biases in preventing firms from taking up profitable decision.
Secondary outcomes
Through link tracking, we will be able to tell which firms clicked the link. Thus, a secondary outcome will be whether a firm clicked the link, regardless of whether they actually completed the form or not. (Note that for the email links, we are able to track the specific user that clicked the link. For the SMS links, we can only track the number of clicks by treatment arm by day but not merge the clicks to individual users.) We will also measure the elasticity of firm sales with respect to the experimental change in fee. Thus we will use asinh(sales) and asinh(number of transactions) as secondary outcomes, where asinh() is the inverse hyperbolic sine transformation, a log-like transformation that can deal with 0s. We will also use levels as robustness checks of these outcomes: sales (winsorized at 5%), number of transactions (winsorized at 5%), and a dummy for whether the firm made any sale in the time period.
Sponsors
Name: CEGA-Visa Financial Inclusion Lab Location: Berkeley Url: https://cega.berkeley.edu/initiative/financial-inclusion-lab/ Name: Lab for Inclusive FinTech (LIFT) at UC Berkeley Location: Berkeley Url: https://haas.berkeley.edu/lift/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords