Inequality concerns, regressive redistribution and public support for university tuition fees

How to cite

Schwerdt, Guido; Bellani, Luna; Berriochoa, Kattalina; Kapteina, Mark. 2020. "Inequality concerns, regressive redistribution and public support for university tuition fees." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006527. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6527-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Guido Schwerdt* , Luna Bellani , Kattalina Berriochoa , Mark Kapteina

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006527
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6527-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-09-07 – 2021-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6527

Abstract

In this trial, we investigate the mechanism that drive public opinion on university tuition fees. Specifically, we examine how perceptions about unequal access to university education and perceptions about a fair burden sharing of study costs drive public support for university tuition fees. To examine our research question, we designed a survey experiment where randomly selected subgroups of the German population receive an information treatment, relative to university tuition fees, to update their knowledge and subsequent preferences for policy changes.
The first information treatment informs respondents that a student’s likelihood of going to university highly depends on his or her parents’ education. The second information treatment confronts respondents with the argument that tax-financed university education paired with a skewed distribution of students’ parental background towards better-educated families leads to an unjust burden sharing of study costs. The goal of our survey experiment is to examine if learning about unequal access to university education or undesired redistributive impacts of current university financing changes public opinion on university tuition fees. We are particularly interested in examining the interaction effect of these two information treatments.

Intervention

To examine the driving forces behind public support for tuition fees at public universities, we design a survey module with an embedded experiment. The module is part of a representative opinion survey on inequality and social mobility in Germany, conducted by the University of Konstanz. Depending on the experimental group, subjects are part of the control without additional information or belong to one of the two treatment groups.

Experimental design

The experiment will consist of three groups, a control and two treatment groups. The treatment groups receive information on the unequal access of university education and the undesired redistributive impact of state-financed university education. Respondents are asked for their support for general tuition fees, downstream tuition fees and income-dependent tuition fees as the outcome variable. A battery of control variables will be solicited in the survey as well. We conduct the experiment in a sample of 6,000 adults aged 18 years and older. The German survey institute, KANTAR is doing the fieldwork of the survey. KANTAR is going to manage the recruitment and collect the data via an online platform. Therefore, our participants answer the survey questions autonomously on their own digital devices. The randomization is done by KANTAR at the individual level.

Our experiment has two stages. In the first stage, respondents will be randomly assigned to the control group (p=1/2) or treatment 1
(p=1/2). In the second stage, respondents will be assigned to the control group (p=1/2) or treatment 2 (p=1/2).

Control group:
No additional information

Treatment 1:
Information set about a student’s likelihood of going to a public university, dependent on his or her parents’ education.

Treatment 2:
Information set about undesired redistribution from the bottom to the top with tax-financed public universities. This information
is presented as part of a survey question that only respondents in the treatment condition receive. The question elicits the support for
the argument that a state-financed university education has redistributive impacts.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is carried out by the survey company KANTAR, using a computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization Unit at the individual level.
Clusters
6,000 individuals
Observations
Sample size: 6,000 individuals (aged 18 years and older)
Arms
Sample size by treatment arms: 6,000 individuals, 1/4 (app. 1500) will be assigned to each of the four experimental groups.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes of interest are subjects’ support for different types of tuition fees at public universities. We elicit traditional tuition fees payed in advance as well as income-contingent tuition fees payed after graduation and tuition fees, which depend on the income of the parents. Question wording General tuition fees – “Are you in favor or against that students, who study at a university or college in Germany, have to cover a share of their study costs with tuition fees?” Downstream uition fees – “In other countries, there are tuition fees at public universities which are only charged after graduation when the former students earn income. These DOWNSTREAM TUITION FEES only have to be repaid if their annual income is above a certain threshold.This is intended to ensure access to higher education for all, even in a fee-financed higher education system. Are you in favor or against that university or college students in Germany bear a share of their study costs with DOWNSTREAM TUITION FEES?” Tuition fees dependent on parents’ income – “In some countries, there are INCOME-DEPENDENT TUITION FEES at public universities which are based on the income of parents, so that students from wealthy families pay higher fees than students from less wealthy families. Grants (like the German BAföG) are paid for students from socially disadvantaged households. In this way, access to higher education is to be made possible for all, even with a fee-financed higher education system. Are you in favor or against that university or college students in Germany bear a share of their study costs with INCOME-DEPENDENT TUITION FEES?” Answer categories: 5-point scale: 1=”I am strongly against it”, 2=”I am more against it”,3=”I am neither in favor not against it”, 4=”I am more in favor of it”, 5=”I am strongly in favor of it”
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes of interest are subjects’ perception of unequal opportunities in the German education system. Question wording What do you think, is inequality of opportunities for children from different social backgrounds a serious problem in the German education system? Answer categories: 5-point scale: 1=“No problem at all”, 2=”a small problem”, 3=”an intermediate problem”, 4=”a serious problem”, 5=”a very serious problem”

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords