Anticarrots and Athletic Gym Membership

How to cite

Ayres, Ian; Mattiacci, Giuseppe Dari. 2015. "Anticarrots and Athletic Gym Membership." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000650. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.650-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ian Ayres* , Giuseppe Dari Mattiacci

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000650
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.650-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2015-06-01 – 2017-09-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D03
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/650

Abstract

This experiment will test whether the experience of resisting temptation to quit an activity or task boosts subjects’ determination to complete that task.

We pursue this question through a collaboration with a gym to randomly offer some new members the chance to give up their membership and have their membership fee refunded. Our hypothesis is that those who are presented with and resist the temptation will come to the gym more often and renew their membership at higher rates. In particular, we want to test whether the group of people who are offered a temptation to quit the gym ends up exercising more – even after including (in our intent to treat analysis) those students who accept the temptation and quit their gym membership.

By rejecting a temptation a person is able to learn something about herself, which in turn will increase her commitment to a certain activity or task. Bénabou and Tirole (2004) map a theoretical framework for “willpower activities” like resisting temptation. They hypothesize that resisting temptation is “hard” information that even people with imperfect recall about their state of mind—for example, being committed to going to the gym—can use to build an enduring image of themselves. Resisting the temptation provides the actor information about his ability to commit to a course of action and hence about the likelihood of success. This new information will, in turn, make it easier and more attractive to stay on the task rather than quitting. Our experiment will test this theory.

Intervention

On their second visit to the gym within a week of registering, one-third of these new members will be randomly presented at a computer terminal with one of three treatments. Members assigned to each treatment group will see a different initial screen; all members will then be shown a screen asking the member to rate his or her satisfaction with them gym.

Experimental design

The experiment focuses on new members at the gym, who have already demonstrated additional interest in exercising by going to the gym twice in the first week of their memberships. We limit our subjects to this population because these new members have a commitment level that is high enough that they are likely to resist our temptations but still malleable and subject to updating based on new information about themselves.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is performed by the gym's computer system.
Randomization unit
The assignment is random and immutable, stratified by contract type with treatment assignments for each contract type made in random permuted blocks of size X (where X is the number of active treatment groups). In practice, here is an example with 3 groups: for each contract type, the system randomly assigns every new incoming customer to group A, B or C. The assignment is made in random permuted blocks of 3: this means that when the first new customer for a particular contract type comes in, the system generates a random permutation of the letters {A, B, C}. For instance, if the generated permutation is {B, A, C}, then the customer is assigned to group B. The next customer is assigned to group A and the next one to group C. If a new customer arrives (the fourth customer), the system generates a new permutation. Say, this time it is {B, C, A}, and the system proceeds as before. The system generates a new permutation for every block of three new customers. This procedure is followed for each contract type independently. We should be able to add / delete contract types easily before the experiment starts and to selectively stop the experiment for some contract types and not for others. The assignment is used only for this experiment and is not communicated / visible to the personnel or the customer.
Clusters
8 contract types
Observations
1500 new gym members
Arms
We expect to have 1500 participants in the experiment over a twelve month period, and for each treatment group to have approximately 500 participants.
Primary outcomes
Primary: Decision to quit, satisfaction with gym, decision to extend gym subscription after initial gym contract ends, frequency of attending the gym (at week, month, semester, year frequencies), and various measures of subsequent academic achievement and satisfaction. Secondary outcomes will include tests of heterogeneous treatment effects with regard to several pre-treatment variables, including: language, gender, marital status, postcode of residence, work-study status, academic degree, academic major, academic year, academic grades, number of credits per semester, level of difficulty of academic classes, number of classes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords