Causal Misperception and Persistent Fertilizer Overuse in China
How to cite
Lin, Wei; Wang, Ao; Chen, Binkai. 2020. "Causal Misperception and Persistent Fertilizer Overuse in China." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006477. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6477-2.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Leveraging administrative data from a province-wide soil-testing program in China,While under-adoption of technology in agriculture is widely discussed, the inappropriate use of technology/input has become a matter of concern. We find strong evidence that farmers in China tend to overuse nitrogen fertilizer and underuse fertilizers in other dimensions, including phosphorus and potassium. Such decision making is affected by the crops' growing stages before the ripening, in which nitrogen provides observable signals on plants while phosphorus and potassium do not. We propose two randomized controlled trials to examine the effects of noticing/improved learning on the appropriate adoption of fertilizers. Our interventions consist in providing soil testing information, fertilizer recommendations, and technologies to facility farmer's learning.
Intervention
We study interventions to improve fertilizer management among rice farmers in China by providing time-specific and plot-specific information and decision support that helps farmers rebalance nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium use without reducing yields.
In March 2020, we implemented three interventions: (i) plot-specific soil-testing information (T1); (ii) soil-testing information plus customized, plot- and time-specific fertilizer recommendations delivered through a mobile application (T2); and (iii) the same app-based recommendations plus in-person training by agricultural extension agents, with emphasis on the roles of phosphorus and potassium in improving yields and profits (T3).
In November 2020, we introduced a leaf color chart intervention. The chart is a low-cost visual decision aid that helps farmers compare rice leaf greenness with calibrated reference colors when deciding whether additional nitrogen fertilizer is needed.
In the late-August 2026 long-term follow-up, we implement a short randomized in-survey decision-aid experiment among relevant follow-up respondents. Some respondents receive a standardized reminder and demonstration on how to use the leaf color chart before completing incentivized decision tasks, while others complete the same tasks without this reminder.
Experimental design
We partner with local agricultural extension services to study fertilizer management among rice farmers in China. The original experiment surveyed 1,200 households in 200 villages. Villages were randomly assigned to four arms: control, soil-testing information, soil-testing information plus app-based fertilizer recommendations, and soil-testing information plus app-based recommendations plus extension-agent training.
After the first follow-up survey, we introduced a leaf color chart intervention to help farmer to for nitrogen top-dressing decisions in 2020 November. In the 2026 long-term follow-up, we revisit the original respondents and conduct a short randomized in-survey experiment. Some respondents receive a standardized leaf-color-chart reminder before completing incentivized decision tasks, while others complete the same tasks without the reminder. We measure fertilizer behavior, beliefs, nutrient knowledge, yields, profits, and decision-task performance.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.