Direct Demand Registration

How to cite

Schaner, Simone; Pande, Rohini; Khanna, Madhulika; Moore, Charity. 2020. "Direct Demand Registration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006456. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6456-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Simone Schaner* , Rohini Pande , Madhulika Khanna , Charity Moore

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006456
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6456-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-09-28 – 2021-03-31
Countries
India (Bihar)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6456

Abstract

The most vulnerable and marginalized citizens - though eligible - are often excluded from safety net programs, even when schemes are self-targeted. The project considers India's workfare guarantee, MGNREGA, which is designed to provide guaranteed work to citizens who request, or "demand" work. Our study directly elicits demand from vulnerable populations, then provides local leaders and program administrators with aggregate information about local work demand. We randomize information provision at two levels to understand complementarities in information sharing across government tiers. We also randomize which communities' work demand is made most salient to higher-level officials, to understand the extent to which there are spillovers or crowding out in service provision. Our study will also explore the role of implementers’ beliefs about work demand in affecting safety-net access, and assess how closing perception gaps related to interest in working affect our outcomes of interest.

Intervention

We will study the role of information at multiple levels of government hierarchy on accountability to citizens’ requests for short-term employment under India’s public works guarantee program, MGNREGA. Using an IVR survey, we will directly solicit interest in working under the program among a high-vulnerability group, migrants who have returned to their home state of Bihar after the Covid-19 pandemic-related lockdowns. We will then share information about migrant interest in work with officials at the block- (supervisory) and Panchayat-levels (village cluster) responsible for implementing MGNREGA. This information will be shared in a format that will closely mimic the internal communication shared by the Government of Bihar. We will run a second IVR survey of migrants to understand how access to the safety net program changes for migrants and utilize administrative data to understand the impact on the overall access to employment in communities. We will also explore the role of implementers’ beliefs about migrant interest in work on changes in safety net access and well-being.

Experimental design

The sampled panchayats come from 145 blocks which we will divide into two block-level intervention nodes:

A.1: Block officials not given the information
A.2: Block officials given the information

A cross-cutting intervention will randomize Panchayat within the control and treatment arms of the block-level intervention. In the treatment arm, local officials, elected and appointed, will receive information about MGNREGA demand among migrants’ families. Since only a random subsample of Panchayats will be included in the information that we will share with block-level officials in the treatment arm, we will equally divide the sample of 1,334 Panchayats across 14 districts in Bihar into six intervention nodes:

B.1: Block officials not given the information + Panchayat officials given the information-sharing product
B.2: Block officials not given the information + Panchayat officials not given the information-sharing product
B.3: Block officials given the information + Panchayat is on the block list + Panchayat officials given the information-sharing product
B.4: Block officials given the information + Panchayat is on the block list + Panchayat officials not given the information-sharing product
B.5: Block officials given the information + Panchayat is not on the block list + Panchayat officials given the information-sharing product
B.6: Block officials given the information + Panchayat is not on the block list + Panchayat officials not given the information-sharing product

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was conducted in the office via a Stata program.
Randomization unit
The intervention of sharing information with the block-level officials is at the block level. Further, a random subsample of Panchayats will be included in the list shared with the block-level officials. The intervention of sharing information with Panchayat-level officials and leaders is at the Panchayat level.
Clusters
145 clusters
Observations
Elected and contractual Panchayat-level officials form 1,334 Panchayats, contractual block-level officials from 145 blocks, and IVR calls to 403,490 unique phone numbers in 14 districts
Arms
We will almost equally divide 1,334 Panchayats into six intervention nodes. Panchayats are divided into six intervention nodes such that the block-level treatment arm that does not provide any information-sharing packages to block-level officials (A1) has two Panchayat-level intervention nodes (B1, B2) and the treatment arm that provides information-sharing packages to block-level officials (A2) has four intervention nodes (B3, B4, B5, B6). Therefore, about one-third of the 145 blocks will be placed in the treatment arm that does not provide any information-sharing packages, and the remaining two-thirds will be placed in the treatment arm that provides information-sharing packages. We will reach out to 403,490 unique phone numbers; other research we have completed using IVR surveys suggests we can expect a response rate between 15% and 20%, leaving us with responses from roughly 60,524 to 80,698 migrants, almost equally split across the six intervention nodes.
Primary outcomes
Our analysis will focus on the following families of outcomes: 1) Officials’ beliefs about the demand for work under MGNREGA. 2) Demand for work under MGNREGA.* 3) Steps taken to ensure access to work: These include number of job cards provided, additional funds requested for etc.* ** 4) Work provided under MGNREGA* Outcomes marked by a single asterisk (*) will be measured using IVR surveys with migrants. Outcomes marked by a double asterisk (**) will be measured using phone surveys with officials.
Secondary outcomes
In addition to the outcomes listed above, we examine the effect on the following secondary outcomes: 1) Return Migration decisions* 2) Measures of target households’ well-being* Outcomes marked with a single asterisk (*) will be measured using IVR surveys with migrants.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords