What could possibly go wrong? Predictable Misallocation in Simple Debt Repayment Experiments

How to cite

Gärtner, Florian; Semmler, Darwin; Bannier, Christina. 2020. "What could possibly go wrong? Predictable Misallocation in Simple Debt Repayment Experiments." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006400. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6400-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Florian Gärtner* , Darwin Semmler , Christina Bannier

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006400
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6400-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-08-01 – 2020-09-01
Countries
Germany (), United States of America ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6400

Abstract

How do people repay debt? In a simple debt repayment experiment we provide subjects with two credit cards with different interest rates and levels of debt that are to be repaid. From a rational choice perspective, this is arguably one of the simplest financial decisions. Nevertheless, we observe severe deviations from optimal, i.e. debt minimizing, repayment decisions with one particularly persistent type of misallocation that has not been found before. In consecutive experiments we show that this and further fallacies are predictable so that behavior can be steered towards more efficient repayment decisions.

Intervention

We test in an online and lab context wether people repay debts optimally, i.e. in an interest-minimizing way. We also try to predict patterns in deviations from optimal behavior, and try to increase optimal behavior.

Experimental design

We use an incentivized debt repayment experiment to test how our participants use income to repay debts. We endow our subjects with two virtual credit card accounts, which both have 2200$ virtual debts and charge 3% or 5% interest rate per round, respectively. In each of the ten rounds subjects get a virtual income of 250$ that they can use to repay these debts. We meassure how much money is NOT used to repay the 5% card.
In experiment #1, we test if the basic paradigm works on MTurk and in the lab.
In experiment #2, we test if we can use the way we present information to increase or decrease optimal (=interest minimizing) behavior. Same experimental design as described, but some variation in the way we present information.
In experiment #3, we test if we can predict seven non-optimal repayment strategies, using a modified one shot game version of our experiment. We design seven pairs of scenarios ("scenario" being defined as a single combination of starting debts, interest rates and income) in which we either try to provoke a certain repayment heuristic, or suppress it. Every scenario pair differs in exactly one value, except for one, where two values differ.

Design details

Randomization method
In experiment #1, we replicate MTurk results in the lab to show that both subject pools behave comperable. Randomizing here is not necessary. In experiment #2, we post sessions of all three treatments on MTurk at the same time using the same wording to advertize them. Technically this is self selection which could be seen as participants self-selecting themselves into a lab experiment where treatment 1 is conducted in one session and treatment 2 in another. Since participants cannot differentiate the treatments, there is no variable to self select for. Experiment #3 has only one treatment.
Randomization unit
Session
Clusters
Overall planned: 820
Observations
Overall planned: 820
Arms
Experiment #1: 130 on MTurk, 100 in the lab Experiment #2: 130 per treatment. Experiment #1 is a replication of the control group of experiment #2, we do not double count th MTurk treatment. Experiment #3: only one treatment, 330.
Primary outcomes
Misallocation of income
Secondary outcomes
To test if financial literacy leads to more optimal behavior

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords