Material hardship and mental health among low-income families during COVID-19: experimental evidence from an unconditional cash transfer

How to cite

Jacob, Brian; Shaefer, Luke; Pilkauskas, Natasha. 2020. "Material hardship and mental health among low-income families during COVID-19: experimental evidence from an unconditional cash transfer." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006398. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6398-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Brian Jacob* , Luke Shaefer , Natasha Pilkauskas

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006398
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6398-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-09-09 – 2021-10-10
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6398

Abstract

A large body of research finds that communities of concentrated poverty - defined as having a poverty rate between 30 and 40 percent - face many serious challenges: higher crime rates coupled with poor physical and mental health outcomes, lower levels of educational attainment, and weaker labor market outcomes. These same communities have been especially hard hit by the COVID-19 pandemic. High-poverty counties have experienced a much higher virus mortality rate (19.3 deaths per 1,000 in counties with at least a 20-percent poverty rate, more than double the rate for counties with poverty rates below five percent), and a higher confirmed case rate in at least one state. The most disadvantaged families also appear to be the least likely to benefit from some of the supports provided through the CARES act such as the economic impact payment, and existing research suggests that these highly disadvantaged families may see the biggest improvement in material hardship from income transfers. This study will investigate the effects of a one-time, unconditional cash transfer on families who live in zip codes in the United States with poverty rates greater than or equal to 35 percent. Randomly selected recipients will be surveyed approximately six weeks after receiving the lump-sum payment and their responses to questions about material hardship, mental health, child well-being, partner relationships, and parenting practices will be compared against those of a control group. Results will inform policy debates about the efficacy of cash transfers during acute economic crises.

Intervention

As part of its charitable mission, the nonprofit organization GiveDirectly, is providing a sample of low-income families in the U.S. a one-time cash transfer of $1,000 to help mitigate the financial stress associated with the COVID-19 pandemic. The intervention is a one-time, $1,000 lump-sum cash payment. Families may use the money as they choose (i.e., there are no restrictions on how they spend the money). As a one-time, lump sum payment this aid does not impact other public assistance benefits. Families are selected randomly from a sample of individuals who are receiving federal assistance through the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). The payment is completely unanticipated and is described as an effort to provide cash relief to Americans in need during the COVID-19 pandemic. Individuals are not required to participate in the research project, or fulfill any other obligations, in order to receive the cash payment.

Experimental design

The sample will be drawn from a set of families receiving benefits through the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) who utilize the FreshEBT mobile app (“app users”) to manage their benefits. App users who live in zipcodes with poverty rates of at least 35% are eligible for the intervention. Among this set, we will randomly select treatment and control individuals. Individuals selected for the treatment group will be notified via a banner on the FreshEBT app; control individuals will receive no such banner. Roughly six weeks following the intervention, we will reach out to individuals in both the treatment and control groups via a banner in the app, inviting them to participate in a research study about their experiences during COVID. Individuals who agreed to participate in the research study will be sent a link to a short online survey. Participants will be compensated $10 for completing the survey.

Design details

Randomization method
We will draw a random sample of individuals, stratifying on whether or not the individual began using the FreshEBT app prior to March 1, 2020 and a three-category measure of the generosity of the social welfare benefits in which the individual lives (as measured by the maximum TANF benefits for a three-person household in the state). This will give us a total of six strata. We plan to use the re-randomization method outlined in Lock and Rubin (2012) to ensure covariate balance. To analyze the results of the experiment, we will use randomization inference that is appropriate for the re-randomization scheme we conducted.
Randomization unit
The individual
Clusters
Roughly 20,000 individuals
Observations
Roughly 20,000 individuals
Arms
10,000 individuals in each of two arms (one treatment and one control)
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes in this study will be composite measures of material hardship and mental health. We will measure these outcomes roughly 6 weeks post intervention. In addition to looking at the effect of the intervention on the full sample for both outcomes, we also plan to examine the impact of the intervention on particularly disadvantaged individuals in our sample. We plan to define this subgroup in two ways: (i) using a simple measure of total household income last month; (ii) using a composite measure of predicted material hardship based on other individual responses. Test 1 - Material hardship, Full sample Test 2 - Material hardship, low-income sample Test 3 - Material hardship, low-income with children Test 4 - Mental health, full sample Test 5 - Mental health, low-income sample
Secondary outcomes
We intend to conduct a variety of secondary (i.e., exploratory) analyses guided by theory and prior literature.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords