The Impact of Personalized Telephone Outreach on Health Insurance Choices

How to cite

Myerson, Rebecca; Menashe, Isaac; Feher, Andrew; Yin, Wesley; Tilipman, Nicholas. 2020. "The Impact of Personalized Telephone Outreach on Health Insurance Choices." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006391. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6391-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rebecca Myerson* , Isaac Menashe , Andrew Feher , Wesley Yin , Nicholas Tilipman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006391
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6391-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-11-01 – 2019-01-31
Countries
United States of America (California)
JEL codes
I13, I18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6391

Abstract

Many Americans have a limited understanding or information about health insurance. Limited awareness of plan options, the availability of subsidies, and plan costs make enrolling and choosing plans difficult. The goal of the project is to assess whether a personalized information intervention can help health insurance marketplaces improve take-up and choice quality, and improve market stability. Specifically, the project will shed light on the following questions:
I. What is the effect of personalized phone outreach on enrollment (take-up) and the risk mix of consumers in the marketplace?
II. How do personalized phone calls affect consumers’ decision of which plan to choose?
III. Are personalized outbound calls particularly effective with certain hard-to-reach populations?
IV. Phone calls are resource intensive; what are the financial implications for the Marketplace and for the insurance market generally of a phone-based intervention to encourage take-up?

Intervention

To understand the effect of a personalized information intervention on health insurance enrollment and plan choice, Covered California implemented telephone consultations during the open enrollment period for 2019 coverage to help inform consumers of their plan options, costs, plan benefits, and assist in enrollment. In this intervention, eligible consumers who had not yet picked a plan by a date close to the deadline were randomly selected to receive no phone call, or a call with a Service Center Representative (SCR) who would discuss their health insurance options with them. In contrast to low-touch interventions, which passively inform consumers about plan options, this intervention assisted consumers more intensively and interactively.
Because call-center time is a scarce resource during the open enrollment period, and it was known in advance that not all eligible consumers could be reached, Covered California implemented the outbound call campaign with a randomized control group. We propose to use administrative data on health insurance choices and phone calls from this randomized controlled trial to understand how personalized assistance informs take-up, plan selections, and costs. The data gathered from the trial include consumers’ random treatment assignment, personal characteristics, and subsequent health insurance decisions.

Experimental design

This is a two-arm research design where approximately 30 percent of cases were assigned to a control group and the 70 percent of cases were assigned to the treatment group. A description of these two arms follows:

Arm 1. Treatment arm (N1=55,519): These consumers were placed in a list to receive a call from an SCR. The goal of the call was to provide information about their likely eligibility for coverage through Covered California, provide personalized information about plan options, and provide live assistance in choosing a plan including answering on-the-spot questions. If the call went to voicemail, the SCR left a voicemail instructing the recipient to call the service center hotline if they would like further assistance. In total, 39,309 members of the treatment group had their file reviewed to make sure they were still eligible. Those who were eligible received an outbound call from a SCR if staff were available. In the end, 27,123 received an outbound call and 28,396 did not receive a call before the end of open enrollment.

Arm 2. Control arm (N2=24,003): No phone call was placed to these consumers.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization occurred at the household level and was based on the last digit of the individual case ID. Cases that end in 1, 2, or 3 were assigned to the control group, and cases that end in any other number were assigned to the treatment group. Preliminary balance checks support the validity of randomization, and further checks are proposed as part of the analysis plan.
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
N/A
Observations
During the 2019 Open Enrollment period, Covered California identified 79,522 individuals with initiated paperwork to obtain Covered California health insurance coverage for the 2019 coverage year who had yet to select a plan and enroll. This group comprises our study sample.
Arms
Treatment arm (N1=55,519): These households were placed in a list to receive a call from an SCR. Those who were eligible received an outbound call from a SCR if staff were available. In the end, 27,123 received an outbound call and 28,396 did not receive a call before the end of open enrollment. Arm 2. Control arm (N2=24,003): No phone call was placed to these consumers.
Primary outcomes
Selecting a plan; effectuated enrollment
Secondary outcomes
Choice quality; the risk mix of enrollees; engagement with the intervention

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords