Structural Analysis of Xenophobia

How to cite

Hwang, Yujung; Deng, Huan. 2020. "Structural Analysis of Xenophobia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006365. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6365-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yujung Hwang* , Huan Deng

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006365
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6365-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2021-03-23 – 2021-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J15, Z13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6365

Abstract

This is a registry for our pilot survey. We will estimate a structural model of anti-Chinese xenophobia using an exogenous variation from an information randomized controlled trial. The structural model explains anti-Chinese xenophobia using two motivations, intrinsic and reputational. Intrinsic motivation is captured by a measure which we call “anti-Chinese animus”. It is measured by self-reports in multiple questions. To defend these measures from potential social desirability bias, we ask List randomization questions. Reputational motivation is captured by people’s concern about other people's perception of their anti-Chinese animus if their behaviors are publicly observable.

The intrinsic and reputational motivations will jointly determine people’s xenophobic actions against Chinese. To measure xenophobic behaviors, we will use three outcome measures: a petition, a dictator game, and a donation question. The dictator game is an incentivized survey item with real money at stake, and the other two questions ask about intentions to donate and to sign a petition.

To achieve this purpose, we have an information RCT. We will randomly choose half of the respondents and show them an animation that describes rising anti-Chinese sentiment in the US, the control group will not see the animation. The animation aims to shift respondents’ perception of the acceptability of xenophobic behaviors against Chinese, which can potentially change the reputational motivation.

Intervention

Our intervention is an information provision. The treatment group will see one animation about rising anti-Chinese sentiment in the US. The control group will not see the animation.

Besides, we ask List randomization questions to assess potential social desirability bias in anti-Chinese sentiment and perception about racial animus against Chinese in the U.S.

Experimental design

To improve the quality of our survey, we will insert a soft commitment question at the beginning of the survey as well as two attention check questions at important locations.

The soft commitment question will appear right after the consent form prompting the respondents to pay attention. We will tell the respondents that they can contribute to scientific research and social welfare by providing accurate and honest responses. And they need to choose “Yes, I agree to do so” to proceed.

To further guarantee the quality of our survey, we use two attention check questions to screen out survey participants who pay little attention to the survey. The first attention check question will appear right before the RCT, while the second one will appear right before questions to measure xenophobic actions. In the first attention check question, we ask respondents how they are currently feeling, but we tell them to check only the “None of the above” option in the middle of the question. Survey participants who fail to pay attention to our message and choose any other choices will be screened out. The second attention check question uses the same trick except that we ask the respondents which device they are using to participate in the survey. We ask them to check “Other” as a correct answer.

To remove any order effect, we randomize the order of multiple choices when we measure racist actions.

Design details

Randomization method
We randomize using a Qualtrics randomizer.
Randomization unit
We do individual level randomization.
Clusters
100 in the pilot survey and 3000 in the main survey.
Observations
100 in the pilot survey and 3000 in the main survey.
Arms
50% of the sample is in the treatment arm and 50% of the sample is in the control arm.
Primary outcomes
We have three primary sets of outcome variables. The first set of outcome variables is about anti-Chinese animus. The second set of outcome variables is about the perception about anti-Chinese xenophobia in the US. The third set of outcome variables is three measurements of xenophobic behaviors.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords