Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation in Financial Transactions: Evidence from Islamic Credit Cards
How to cite
Fiorin, Stefano; Bursztyn, Leonardo; Gottlieb, Daniel; Kanz, Martin. 2015. "Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation in Financial Transactions: Evidence from Islamic Credit Cards." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000635. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.635-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We partner with an Islamic bank in Indonesia which sends text messages to its customers who are late on their credit card debt repayment. We randomize the content of the text messages across customers: some receive simple reminders; some receive information about the financial consequences of being late on debt repayment; others receive information about the religious doctrine on being late on debt repayment. The purpose of the texts is to encourage repayment by reminding borrowers that they are late on their credit card repayments, or by leveraging extrinsic motivation (informing them about about the financial consequences of non-repayment) or intrinsic motivation (informing them about about the religious consequences of non-repayment).
We test - if our texts influence repayment of the customers, and - whether the mechanism behind the effect is a change in beliefs about the consequences of delaying payment. We also test- whether this effects depends on the religiosity and the trust in institutions of the customers and the environment in which they live and - if intrinsic motivation for repaying debt can be crowded out by financial incentives.
Finally the bank offers restructuring offers to some customers, and complement our analysis on willingness to pay with a test of the effectiveness of changing customers ability to pay. Using the take-up of restructuring offers we also plan to estimate the monetary value of religious and non-religious reminders about credit card repayment.
Intervention
We partner with an Islamic bank in Indonesia and work with a sample of its customers being late on their credit card debt repayment. We send text messages to these customers randomizing the content of the text with the purpose of encouraging their repayment. We also offer restructuring offers to a limited amount of customers.
Experimental design
We partner with an Islamic bank in Indonesia and work with a sample of its customers being late on their credit card debt repayment.
We randomize those customers in nine groups.
(1) Customers in group 1 serve as control and receive not text message (apart from a reminder which the bank sends to all of its credit card customers on the due date);
(2) Customers in group 2 receive a simple reminder asking for repayment;
(3) Customers in group 3 receive a text informing customers of the existence of a credit registry which all banks can consult (and asking for repayment);
(4) Customers in group 4 receive a text informing customers of the existence of a credit registry and stating this affect their ability to get credit since all banks consult the registry (and asking for repayment);
(5) Customers in group 5 receive a religious placebo message reporting a quote from the Prophet (and asking for repayment);
(6) Customers in group 6 receive a religious message reporting a quote from the Prophet saying that "Delay in paying debt by a person who can afford is an injustice" (and asking for repayment);
(7) Customers in group 7 receive both the message about credit registry of group 4 and the religious message of group 6;
(8) Customers in group 8 receive tow simple reminders asking for repayment;
(9) Customers in group 9 are offered restructuring offers by phone calls (details to be defined).
We test whether the content of the text message influences repayment behavior.
For the religious text (group 6) we test whether:
- our text increases repayment of credit card debt;
- our text changes beliefs about the severeness of the religious consequences of delaying repayment;
- the effects depend on the importance the customers (and people living close to them) gives to the rules of Islam and Sharia Law.
For the credit registry texts (group 3 and 4) we test whether:
- informing customers about the existence of a credit registry increases repayment of credit card debt;
- informing customers also about the effectiveness of the credit registry has an additional effect on repayment of credit card debt;
- our text changes beliefs about the severeness of the financial consequences of delaying repayment;
- the effects depend on the confidence the customers (and people living close to them) have in the enforcement of laws and banking contracts.
By sending to some customer both our religious and our credit registry texts (group 7) we test if intrinsic motivation crowds out extrinsic motivation in the context of financial transactions.
Finally we offer to some customers restructuring offers (group 9), and complement our analysis on willingness to pay with a test of the effectiveness of changing customers ability to pay.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.