Neuroeconomics for development: Eye-tracking to understand migrant remittances

How to cite

Viceisza, Angelino; Torero, Maximo; Nakasone, Eduardo. 2020. "Neuroeconomics for development: Eye-tracking to understand migrant remittances." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006322. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6322-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Angelino Viceisza* , Maximo Torero , Eduardo Nakasone

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006322
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6322-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-05-01 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Guatemala (), Honduras (), El Salvador (), United States of America (Washington DC)
JEL codes
C93, D87, D9, F24, F22, O12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6322

Abstract

Remittances, i.e., money sent by migrants to family and friends, are a key pillar of economic development. Organizations such as the International Fund for Agricultural Development and the World Bank have thus argued for increased transparency and reduced transaction fees via remittance-comparison platforms, i.e., sites like kayak.com but for sending money. This project assesses to what extent (1) information provided through such platforms impacts remittance choices, e.g., by breaking habits; (2) information affects the alignment between choices and stated preferences, potentially impacting welfare; and (3) migrants' visual attention (measured through eye-tracking) moderates the relationship between choices, information, and possibly, welfare. In so doing, this project (i) sheds light on potential reasons for why take-up of comparison platforms has remained low and (ii) contributes to a growing literature on behavioral development. While the data for this project have been collected, they have not been analyzed. So, the purpose of this registration is to discuss (1) how the study was designed/implemented and (2) what analysis will be done (see enclosed pre-analysis plan). Departures from the planned analysis will be identified as part of the research paper and/or a populated pre-analysis plan (Duflo et al. 2020).

Intervention

1. NGO personnel recruited potential participants who had to meet the following criteria: (A) be older than 18; (B) have sent remittances at least four times in the past year to El Salvador, Guatemala, or Honduras; (C) be able to read and use a computer; and (D) not wear bifocal glasses (for purposes of eye-tracking).

2. Participants gave informed consent, were assigned a study ID, and completed a pre-survey (see Docs & Materials).

3. Each participant reviewed three webpages containing attributes of 10-11 money-transfer operators (MTOs) such as Western Union and MoneyGram (more under Experimental Design). These webpages were offline variants of a World Bank-certified comparison platform. Participants had five minutes to review each page and choose the MTO with which they wanted to send $100 or $300 (randomly determined) to El Salvador, Guatemala, or Honduras (also see step 5). While reviewing webpages and making decisions, participants' eyes were tracked. As part of the experiment instructions, participants were asked not to move back and forth once the eye-tracker had been calibrated, in order to safeguard accuracy of the data.

4. A subset of the participants completed a short post-survey (see Docs & Materials).

5. Participants were paid $50 in cash for completing the study. In addition, one in eight participants won a lottery in which $100 or $300 were sent by means of one of the MTOs chosen in step 3. This increased the chance that decisions made in the study were given careful consideration, as tends to be the case in the day-to-day environment. Lottery winners were notified by phone after the study and asked to confirm the contact information for their preferred recipient in the country of origin. After the money was sent, they were provided with a confirmation number so the recipient could claim the funds.

Experimental design

The experimental design comprised two main treatments: Group A and Group B. Both groups saw three webpages (as explained under Intervention).

The first page was the same across groups. It contained the following attributes for each MTO: the name and logo; the exchange rate, transaction fee, and thus, amount that would arrive; and whether the funds would arrive as a deposit or in cash for pick-up or home delivery.

The second page is where Groups A and B differed. If the participant was in Group A, page 2 added how long the money would take to arrive (i.e., the delivery speed) to page 1. If the participant was in Group B, page 2 added customer reviews instead.

Finally, the third page added customer reviews to page 2 if the participant was in Group A and delivery speed if the participant was in Group B. So, while Groups A and B were the same again by page 3, the order in which additional information had been presented varied.

Assignment to Group A or B was random, since odd study IDs were assigned to A and even IDs were assigned to B.

Participants were also randomly assigned to (i) stakes of $100 or $300 (as referenced previously) and (ii) three possible versions of webpages, which varied in terms of the order of the MTOs and the MTO that had a 50 percent price discount.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
394 individuals. Also see next item.
Observations
In the NSF proposal, we proposed 400 individuals. We actually ended up with 394 individuals.
Arms
There are four treatments: A-$100, A-$300, B-$100, and B-$300. The 394 individuals should be distributed as follows across these treatments: 115, 77, 115, and 77. This is because there was a 50-50 chance of being assigned to A versus B and a 60-40 chance of being assigned to $100 versus $300. The exact sample size per treatment will be verified once the data are analyzed.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is a participant's choice of MTO on a given results page.
Secondary outcomes
We are also interested in (i) the extent to which a participant chooses the same MTO across all three results pages; (ii) the extent to which a participant's typical choice of MTO (elicited in the pre-survey) is the same as what is chosen in (i); (iii) different measures of visual attendance; and (iv) their interactions.
Sponsors
Name: National Science Foundation Location: Washington DC Url: http://www.nsf.gov

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords