The Demand for Voluntary Carbon Sequestration – Experimental Evidence from a Reforestation Project in Germany
How to cite
Bartels, Lara; Kesternich, Martin; Löschel, Andreas. 2020. "The Demand for Voluntary Carbon Sequestration – Experimental Evidence from a Reforestation Project in Germany." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006319. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6319-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A deeper understanding of individual behavior that determines the voluntary provision of environmental public goods is of special importance for climate action where decentralized informal institutions like societal norms and values gain momentum. For achieving the 2°C global temperature target, IPCC scenarios suggest net-zero emissions by around 2050. So far, the experimental literature on individual climate change efforts focuses on the underlying individual willingness-to-pay for CO2 mitigation. As novelty, we investigate voluntary contributions to a negative emission technology in form of a local forest carbon sink. We conduct a framed-field experiment highlighting not only the climate impact, but also the role of local ancillary benefits resulting from the provision of a local forest carbon sink and the importance of the spatial dimension.
Intervention
Our study exploits the demand for voluntary carbon sequestration in form of a reforestation project in Germany. For the intervention, customers of an online comparison platform for electricity tariffs that operates all over Germany are invited to participate in a survey thematically unrelated to the experiment. After completing the online survey, participants were, for the first time, confronted with the opportunity to donate their fixed payment earned in the survey (20€) to a carbon sink project. With the help of an adjustable slider, they could determine if and how much of their fixed payment they wanted to donate. Unknown to the potential donors, subjects were at this stage randomly allocated to one out of the two treatments which only varied in its information about the carbon sinks project.
The first wave of interventions (with the two treatments, sinks (S) and co-benefit sinks (CBS)) took place from 16th to 25th March 2020. A second wave of interventions (with the same two treatments as in the first wave) is planned within the first half of 2021.
Experimental design
Subjects take part in an online survey. After completing the survey they are given the opportunity to donate their fixed payment earned in the survey to a carbon sink project. With the help of an adjustable slider, they could determine if and how much of their fixed payment (20 €) they want to donate.
Participants are randomly allocated to two information treatments, which vary in its information about the carbon sinks project. The sinks (S) treatment gives information on the need for global climate protection and the role of carbon sinks within this process. Also, information on the average CO2 absorption capacities of trees were given and put in reference to the emissions value of a car trip. Then, subjects were asked if and how much they would like to donate for the removal of 100kg CO2 from the atmosphere through a specified afforestation project. The second treatment, the co-benefit sinks (CBS) treatment, contained all the information of the S treatment but also included an extra part that additionally to the CO2 removal stressed the local ancillary benefits from the reforestation project.
Our main hypotheses (H1) is that if subjects value the local benefits adequately we would be able to reject our Null-Hypothesis (H0: WTPCBS = WTPS). Given the variety in places of residence of our subjects, we expect a difference between those who are located close to the reforestation project (and thus reveal some additional local benefits for themselves from planting trees) and those who are located further away. If this holds we would reject the Null-hypothesis (H0: ρ(WTPCBS,d)=0) in our hypothesis H3 which captures the correlation ρ between the physical distance d to the reforestation project and the willingness to pay.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Bartels, Lara, Martin Kesternich und Andreas Löschel (2021), The Demand for Voluntary Carbon Dioxide Removal – Experimental Evidence From an Afforestation Project in Germany, ZEW Discussion Paper Nr. 21-088, Mannheim. https://www.zew.de/publikationen/the-demand-for-voluntary-carbon-dioxide-removal-experimental-evidence-from-an-afforestation-project-in-germany
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.