Changing investors' evaluation practices

How to cite

Miller, Amisha; Montalvao, Joao; Alibhai, Salman; Goldstein, Markus; Lall, Saurabh. 2020. "Changing investors' evaluation practices." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006314. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6314-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Amisha Miller* , Joao Montalvao , Salman Alibhai , Markus Goldstein , Saurabh Lall

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006314
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6314-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-10-20 – 2020-12-25
Countries
Private
JEL codes
L26 (Entrepreneurship)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6314

Abstract

Early stage investors often evaluate startup candidates for investment in highly uncertain environments, where decision outcomes are non-obvious and the majority of startups will fail. Most scholarship has examined how investors work with startups post investment, rather than how investors select startups. Yet this selection process is important as evidence suggests that equity investors concentrate their investments on startups led by white, male founders in California. This is problematic not only for talented diverse founders from elsewhere, but also for any investor concerned with missing promising investment opportunities. Scholars suggest that differences in context can shape which startups are considered or valued, but little is known about the process by which early stage investors evaluate the investment worthiness of deals and the ramifications of these processes on investment decisions. Without this understanding, it is difficult to assess how evaluation processes can be changed to include consideration of more diverse types of founders. How do investment organizations source, evaluate and value early-stage investments? How does this shape the diversity of the founders they consider? We will conduct field experiments with professional and trainee investors to assess the effect of changing two evaluation practices on investment decisions.

Intervention

For the first treatment, we will ask investors to weigh a list of evaluation criteria provided in proportion to their importance before evaluating the startups. Next, we will ask investors to evaluate startups. In contrast, we will ask the control group to weight their criteria after they have evaluated the startups.

For the second treatment, we will edit the term sheet that investors receive and place an additional investment from a “public” fund. After the investor has evaluated, if they respond “no” on our binary startup evaluation question, we will increase the percentage of ownership until investor switches to "yes" or we reach the limit of the deal size.

Experimental design

We will assess the effectiveness of the two treatments on the propensity of investors to invest in a startup founded by a female CEO. Our hypotheses predict that both treatment 1 and treatment 2 will increase the propensity to invest in firms founded by female CEOs.

For treatment 1, we will assess the effect of the treatment on startups led by female CEOs only. We will have a sample size of 100 investor decisions on startups led by a female CEO and we will assess the effect of this treatment using a between subject design. We predict only a directional effect for hypothesis 1 in this study.

We will assess the effect of treatment 2 using a within treatment design, which will result in a sample size of 200 decisions, with 100 decisions made on startups with female founder-CEOs. We will assess the effects on all startups as well as those led by female CEOs. We predict a significant positive effect on all startups, and a directional effect on startups led by female CEOs.

Design details

Randomization method
Qualtrics randomization tool
Randomization unit
Individual decisions
Clusters
First, each investor will make two decisions. Each investor is a cluster. Second, we will cluster by online event, which will result in 2 or more clusters. We have planned 2 events, and need a sample size of 150 investors. Third, we will cluster by the startup pair, which will also signify the industry (either fintech or education) where investments are made. If, after the two events, we have not reached 150 investor responses, we will continue to run events until we reach this sample.
Observations
300 individual decisions, from 150 individual investors
Arms
For treatment 1, I will have a sample size of 100 investor decisions on startups led by a female CEO (50 treatment investors making two decisions each and weighting the criteria before investing, and 50 control investors each making one decision without any treatment, and weighting their criteria after investing). For treatment 2, I will have a sample size of 200 total investor decisions on startups, and 100 investor decisions on startups led by a female CEO, in a within subject design.
Primary outcomes
Propensity to invest in diverse founders

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords