Choice Architecture and Transparency
How to cite
Kujansuu, Essi. 2020. "Choice Architecture and Transparency." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006308. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6308-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Choice Architects design choice environments. In this setting, Choice Architects may use nudges, changes to the environment, that predictably affect behaviour but keep payoffs constant and do not restrain options available. This project investigates how transparency, awareness of the Choice Architects' use of nudges, changes how nudges influence behaviour and how Choice Architects use them. The model distinguishes between System 1 nudges that rely on mental shortcuts (for example, default options) and System 2 nudges that engage reflective thinking (for example, by providing a new way to think about the choice). The model predicts that a) System 1 nudges have less effect under transparency while System 2 nudges have the same effectiveness and 2) the use of System 1 nudges is reduced by transparency while the use of System 2 nudges is increased.
Intervention
The main intervention is an announcement that makes it salient to all participants that nudges are potentially used in the formulation of the next question. This intervention is common to Choice Architects and Decision Makers.
We are also interested in the effects of the nudges themselves. This intervention affects only Decision Makers. Each nudge is thus also an intervention. We have three versions of the question. First, we have a simple question design that deliberately lists the low target first. Second, we have a system 1 nudge that preselects the high target both in the wording and in the software. Third, we have a system 2 nudge that encourages participants to determine which choice is better in terms of risks and benefits before answering the question itself.
Third, to study transition paths, we give all those Choice Architects in the control a delayed transparency treatment by asking them again to choose a question formulation but for another Decision Maker, who this time reads the transparency announcement before seeing the question.
Experimental design
The experiment is a simple Choice Architecture Game with nudges.
In the second experiment, the goal is to test the Decision Maker hypotheses only on women, and to test the Choice Architect decisions on a more experienced group of people, namely, PhD students or PhDs in Social Sciences.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.