Different Approaches to Entrepreneurial Decision-Making: A Field Experiment in Italy

How to cite

Spina, Chiara; Souakri, Anna; Raguseo, Elisabetta; Bacco, Francesca; Battaglia, Daniele; Butticè, Vincenzo; Camuffo, Arnaldo; Colombelli, Alessandra; Colombo, Massimo; Gambardella, Alfonso; Messinese, Danilo; Panelli, Andrea; Paolucci, Emilio; Piva, Evila; Ughetto, Elisa. 2020. "Different Approaches to Entrepreneurial Decision-Making: A Field Experiment in Italy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006263. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6263-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Chiara Spina* , Anna Souakri , Elisabetta Raguseo , Francesca Bacco , Daniele Battaglia , Vincenzo Butticè , Arnaldo Camuffo , Alessandra Colombelli , Massimo Colombo , Alfonso Gambardella , Danilo Messinese , Andrea Panelli , Emilio Paolucci , Evila Piva , Elisa Ughetto

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006263
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6263-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-05-01 – 2022-02-28
Countries
Private
Secondary IDs
M13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6263

Abstract

This project focuses on how entrepreneurs can make decisions under conditions of uncertainty. The goal is to extend prior work that shows that entrepreneurs can improve their ability to make key decisions for the development of their business by adopting a set of practices labelled 'scientific approach'. A scientific approach is a set of routines based on the formulation of theories and predictions tested with data, resembling what scientists do. When entrepreneurs use this approach, they accurately frame and identify the problem they face, while articulating theories, defining testable hypotheses, conducting rigorous tests, and making decisions based on the results of these tests. We conduct a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to obtain rigurous evidence and test the impact of the scientific approach vis-a-vis another popular approach to decision-making, effectuation. When using effectuation, entrepreneurs use a non-predictive approach through which they identify the next steps by gauging what resources they have available, while continuously balancing the interests of self-selected stakeholders with their resources.
Building on two pilot studies (RCTs) conducted in Italy and involving 116 and 250 founders of new startups, we are conducting another RCT with 500 entrepreneurs to understand the conditions under which different approaches to decision-making enable or constrain entrepreneurial action.

Intervention

Entrepreneurs will receive 8 sessions of online training. These sessions will include interactive lectures and coaching by qualified mentors/instructors each working with a subset of the startup sample. Treated and control startups will receive the same amount of training on entrepreneurial decision making (on topics like business model canvas, customers' interviews, minimum viable products/services, concierge/prototype, etc.). One set of treated startups will be taught how to make entrepreneurial decisions according to a scientific approach. Another set of treated startups will be taught how to make entrepreneurial decisions according to an effectuation approach. The third set of entrepreneurs will receive equivalent training without any specific approach. A final set of entrepreneurs will not receive any training.

Experimental design

The RCT focuses on nascent entrepreneurs (defined as those in the process of starting a new business). We do not restrict participation to startups operating in one or a few industries. We advertise the program through digital channels as a general course overseeing all the important aspects of new venture creation. The course is free of charge in order to ensure the participation of firms with limited financial resources. Startups receive training sessions remotely through an online platform. The same amount of training is offered to all three groups in order to ensure comparability. Multiple instructors/coaches will be trained to deliver the training using standard materials, purposely designed for this study. Each instructor/coach teaches three classes (one subgroup of startups treated with the scientific approach, one subgroup of startups treated with an effectuation approach, and one subgroup of control startups). The research team designs, coordinates and oversees all the activities, ensuring that the learning modules and coaching activities are appropriately carried out by the instructors/coaches.

Design details

Randomization method
Pure parallel randomization, done in office by a computer using STATA. After being randomly assigned into one of the four groups (pure control, control, effectuation or scientific), multiple subgroups of startups (of about 35 startups) will be created and randomly matched with the instructors/coaches so that each instructor/coach teaches three subgroups - of approximately 35 startups. Randomization checks: mean values comparison and t-tests across groups.
Randomization unit
Start-up
Clusters
Not clustered
Observations
500 startups X 12 (points in time) = 6000 observations
Arms
500 startups (125 in the scientific group, 125 in the effectuation group, 125 in the control group, 125 in the pure control group)
Primary outcomes
1. Revenue: our main dependent variable is the amount of revenue (euros) 2. Dropout: this is a binary variable that takes value 0 until the firm drops out (they abandon the program and cease the startup), 1 in the time period in which the firm drops out, and it is a missing value thereafter. In order to avoid attrition biases, we will check that the entrepreneurs that leave the program will actually cease any entrepreneurial activity. 3. Pivot: this is the cumulative number of times in which a startup makes a major change to its business model. We defined a change to be major by analyzing whether the entrepreneur moved from the original idea to another idea that changed the core value proposition of the product or service. The research team will also examine potential mechanisms behind these outcomes by collecting variables related to how and when entrepreneurs make decisions. The key mechanism being tested is precision and improvement in the precision of predictions.
Secondary outcomes
The research team is also examining the interaction of the treatments with a number of covariates of interest, including: a) Gender b) Psychological traits c) Perception of competition and information sharing d) Management practices adopted by the entrepreneurial teams e) Well-being f) Accumulation of knowledge g) Passion h) Communication i) Knowledge sharing among team members j) Influence of external mentors k) Role of experience and background in adopting different approaches

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords