How markets shape and promote values: a laboratory experiment

How to cite

Zhang, Sili; Weber, Roberto. 2020. "How markets shape and promote values: a laboratory experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006244. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6244-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sili Zhang* , Roberto Weber

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006244
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6244-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2019-06-03 – 2019-07-05
Countries
Switzerland ()
JEL codes
C92, D12, D22, D91, M14
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6244

Abstract

We study whether market exchange can promote and transmit the values held by market participants. Specifically, we investigate the conjecture that consumers prefer to exchange with sellers whose behavior reflects consumers’ values and that this, in turn, leads to public support for those values by counterparts seeking improved market outcomes. We document in a laboratory experiment that consumers prefer exchanging with counterparts who express support for their values, even when the exchange has no impact on the actual promotion of those values. Specifically, we find that consumers’ willingness-to-pay is increasing in sellers’ donations to organizations supported by consumers, even though the donations have already been made and cannot be influenced by consumers' purchasing decisions. In turn, sellers anticipate such concern and donate more in support of consumers’ values, but only when there are potential mutual benefits from market exchange.

Intervention

The following three treatment interventions are implemented between subjects:
- Matched treatment: each seller will donate to the organization selected by the consumer with whom he or she is matched in each period; each consumer can condition their willingness-to-pay choices on the amount of donation made by the seller.
- Random treatment: each seller will donate to the organization selected by a different consumer than the one with whom he or she is matched; each consumer can condition their willingness-to-pay choices on the amount of donation made by the seller.
- Control treatment: each seller will donate to the organization selected by the consumer with whom he or she is matched in each period; each consumer cannot condition their willingness-to-pay choices on the amount of donation made by the seller.

We also vary, within-subjects, across rounds the following two treatment interventions:
- Market: there are potential gains from exchange in the market.
- No Market: the procedures are identical but there are no potential gains from exchange.

Experimental design

We set up an experimental induced-value market with buyers and sellers in the laboratory using 2 x 3 design. The value preference is implemented in the experiment as a preference for a variety of organizations that support different causes. In our first main betwee-subjects treatment arm (Matched), sellers can make an unconditional donation to the organization selected by the buyer with whom they are matched in each trading period. After the donation choice, we vary whether the interaction occurs in a Market context (where there exists a surplus to be realized from exchange) or in a Non-market context (where there is no surplus). Consumers' willingness-to-pay is elicited via an incentive-compatible BDM mechanism before the price offer is revealed.
We also implement two other between-subjects treatment arms. In Random condition, the organizations to which sellers can make donations are determined randomly from choices made by buyers in previous sessions. We also have a Control condition in which buyers cannot condition their purchasing decisions on the donation made by sellers.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization of between-subjects variation done using a computer to randomly assign sessions to treatment; randomization of within-subjects variation implemented by computer during experiment
Randomization unit
between-subject randomization at the session level; within-subject randomization at the individual level
Clusters
We conducted 16 experimental sessions. Each session consists of around 30 participants.
Observations
484 participants in total.
Arms
The Matched treatment consists of 192 subjects from 6 sessions, the Random treatment consists of 184 subjects from 6 sessions, and the Control treatment consists of 118 subjects from 4 sessions.
Primary outcomes
consumers' willingness-to-pay; sellers' donation
Secondary outcomes
consumers' self-reported value sensitivity when values are aligned and misaligned; sellers' price offer

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords