The Social Dilemma of Big Data

How to cite

Hillebrand, Kirsten; Hornuf, Lars. 2020. "The Social Dilemma of Big Data." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006241. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6241-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kirsten Hillebrand* , Lars Hornuf

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006241
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6241-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-09-13 – 2020-09-25
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C71, H41, I18, O35, Q56
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6241

Abstract

Decision-support systems can influence people in various domains of life. Firms have started implementing these systems via chatbots and other natural language-based assistants. While benefiting from these decision-support systems, individuals provide sensitive and valuable data to the private industry. By using this data, companies may generate additional profits. Moreover, by making their data available, individuals may also promote the common good. Regulators have recently called for efficient tools to let the public collectively benefit from its own data. The study investigates how people may voluntarily upload their data to a database that is used to develop and operate a decision-support system to promote a public good.

Experimental design

We plan an online study with experimental manipulations that rely on between- and within subject designs. The experimental treatments are followed by an online survey to control for confounding variables and characteristics. The experiment follows a 3 x 3 design. The participants will randomly be confronted with varying levels of risk of their data getting leaked and of the impact a smart assistant has on a public good. The experiment considers two different domains, which include the identical 3 x 3 design but vary in the public good that will be promoted by the smart assistant.

Design details

Randomization method
Participants are randomly assigned to the treatments by a designated function by the software Unipark. Randomization is carried out with a random number trigger. I.e. each treatment group is assigned a number, the trigger then selects a random number for each participant, according to which the participants are assigned to the corresponding groups with the identical numbers.
Randomization unit
Randomization will be done on the participant level.
Clusters
No clusters.
Observations
Details: The sample size has been calculated using G*Power (http://gpower.hhu.de) and considers the statistical test (ANOVA), type of analysis (a priori), alpha level (0.05), failed attention check rates (10%), and drop-out rates (35%). In step one, participants are randomly assigned to one of two domains (sustainable health system / sustainable environment). In step two, in line with the 3 x 3 design participants are randomly assigned to one of nine treatment combinations per domain: risk (low, middle, high) x impact (low, middle, high). Thus, there are nine treatment combinations per domain. According to G*Power 105 individuals need to participate in each treatment combination. In step three, participants of each treatment combinations are randomly assigned to either answer a question about the managing parties or the type of algorithm, which results in a total of 36 treatment combinations. According to the G*Power test, each group requires an average sample size of 52.3 participants. Hence, the required overall sample size is at least (36 x 52.3=) 1,883 participants. Although natural persons, numbers have not been rounded when extrapolating to required total sample size as high deviations would occur.
Arms
The respective sample sizes by treatment arm are reported for one of the two domains we consider in the experiment (sustainable health system / sustainable environment). The sample sizes for the other domain are perfectly identical. Risk low / Impact low: n = 105, Risk low / Impact middle: n = 105, Risk low / Impact high: n = 105, Risk middle / Impact low: n = 105, Risk middle / Impact middle: n = 105, Risk middle / Impact high: n = 105, Risk high / Impact low: n = 105, Risk high / Impact middle: n = 105, Risk high / Impact high: n = 105. Managing Parties (MP): Risk low / Impact low: n = 53, MP Risk low / Impact middle: n = 53, MP Risk low / Impact high: n = 53, MP Risk middle / Impact low: n = 53, MP Risk middle / Impact middle: n = 53, MP Risk middle / Impact high: n = 53, MP Risk high / Impact low: n = 53, MP Risk high / Impact middle: n = 53, MP Risk high / Impact high: n = 53. Type of Algorithm (TA): Risk low / Impact low: n = 53, TA Risk low / Impact middle: n = 53, TA Risk low / Impact high: n = 53, TA Risk middle / Impact low: n = 53, TA Risk middle / Impact middle: n = 53, TA Risk middle / Impact high: n = 53, TA Risk high / Impact low: n = 53, TA Risk high / Impact middle: n = 53, TA Risk high / Impact high: n = 53.
Primary outcomes
Individual willingness to upload personal data to a database that is used to develop and operate a decision-support system to promote a public good.
Secondary outcomes
(1) Moral obligation to provide data (2) Relative willingness to provide data, depending on who is the managing party of the database (3) Relative willingness to provide data, depending on the decision-support system's underlying type of algorithm (4) Differences in willingness to provide data depending on the public good to be promoted (sustainable health system / sustainable environment)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords