Improving participation in door-to-door vector control campaigns using behavioral economics

How to cite

Buttenheim, Alison; Paz-Soldan, Valerie; Levy, Michael Z.. 2015. "Improving participation in door-to-door vector control campaigns using behavioral economics." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000620. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.620-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alison Buttenheim* , Valerie Paz-Soldan , Michael Z. Levy

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000620
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.620-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2012-01-20 – 2019-12-15
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/620

Abstract

Door-to-door health campaigns are a critical component of many health promotion, disease prevention, and surveillance efforts in a variety of contexts. Unfortunately, participation in these campaigns is often low, undermining the effectiveness of proven interventions. The dangers of low participation are particularly acute when threshold levels of coverage are needed to prevent disease, as a in vaccination or vector control campaigns. New approaches are needed to understand and influence household decisions to participate in door-to-door public health interventions. In this study, we apply novel basic science discoveries from behavioral economics to increase participation in an ongoing Chagas disease vector control campaign in Arequipa, Peru, where we have collaborated with the Ministry of Health for a decade. Low participation currently threatens the success of the campaign; the greatest barriers to participation reported by household include lost work hours, concerns about insecticide, and allergies. The overarching hypothesis of our study is that low rates of participation in door-to-door vector control campaigns can be significantly improved through interventions that incorporate the realities of human decision-making and behavior change. Recent insights from the field of behavioral economics suggest that common cognitive biases and mental shortcuts- such as present bias and following social norms- contribute to low participation in vector control campaigns, as they do in other domains. Through new formative work, we identified three interventions with high potential to overcome these biases and thereby increase participation: responsive scheduling with advance commitment, neighbor recruitment, and contingent group lotteries. The core of our proposed study is a cluster-randomized field trial to evaluate the impact of these three interventions. We first determine the rate of participation under each intervention, and then measure the programmatic and participant costs associated with each, to assess comparative cost-effectiveness. In addition, to address concerns about whether behavioral economic interventions lead to motivation crowd out- when extrinsic motivation for healthy behaviors reduces intrinsic motivation- we assess whether exposure to these interventions is correlated with decreased household participation in three subsequent health campaigns. The development, refinement, and scale-up of our interventions will yield evidence-based practices that can increase the impact of health promotion and disease prevention efforts in the United States and globally.

Intervention

A. Current practice (control). The control arm will consist of the current Ministry of Health campaign. Printed campaign materials are distributed to households. Health promoters request permission to spray and schedule insecticide spray for the next day. Promoters can answer any questions or concerns.

B. Advance commitment responsive scheduling. Households are approached 2-4 weeks prior to the spray date and asked to commit, in advance, to participate. Households that agree to participate are offered convenient 2-hour appointment windows on a future spray date. Planning prompts, which encourage households to make a specific plan to prepare the home for spraying, are also offered. Households can request a paper or text message reminder prior to their scheduled appointment, and will be able to reschedule their appointment if necessary. Households are then also visited before the previously scheduled appointment by the health promoter to confirm the appointment.

C. Neighbor recruitment. One month prior to targeted spray dates, study staff approach formal community leaders (Ministry of Health-trained health promoters, block captains, and elected community officials) and informal neighborhood opinion leaders (corner store owners, day care coordinators), explain the campaign in depth, and ask leaders to serve as neighbor recruiters. Each recruiter is given promotional t-shirts, a clipboard, and the same educational materials used by campaign staff. Recruiters are asked to promote the campaign to a pre-specified list of 10-12 nearby households, wear the campaign t-shirts regularly, and distribute additional Ministry of Health materials.

D. Contingent group sweepstakes. Contiguous households are assigned to sweepstakes groups of 5-7 households. Sweepstakes groups are randomly assigned a lottery number. Households whose lottery group is selected and who participated in spraying will win a hardware store voucher of 50 nuevo soles. If 100% of households in the selected group participated in the spraying, each participating household wins a 100 nuevo soles hardware store voucher. Study staff will inform households about their lottery group, lottery number, and their lottery drawing date (using the Peru national Tinka Megabol). Winners will be notified and vouchers distributed to their homes within 1-2 weeks of the drawing.

Experimental design

Cluster-randomized community field trial.

Design details

Randomization method
We will calculate the Mahalanobis distance among clusters based on infestation and participation in the previous spraying campaign (6 months before). We will use datasets from previous spraying campaigns in the city of Arequipa to build a logistic regression model and estimate the impact of infestation in the previous campaign and participation on the previous campaign on participation on a subsequent campaign. We will use the exponentiated coefficients from this model to give different weights to the variables for the estimation of the distances between observations. To balance these two confounding variables (infestation and previous participation), we will divide the geographical clusters in 4 blocks based on the estimated Mahalanobis distance between observations. Finally, we will randomly assign clusters from each block to one of the four intervention arms.
Randomization unit
Clusters of approximately 100 households
Clusters
56 clusters of 100 households/cluster
Observations
5,600 households
Arms
1,400 households control, 1,400 households contingent group lottery, 1,400 responsive scheduling with advanced commitment, and 1,400 neighbor recruitment.
Primary outcomes
Household participation in the vector control campaign.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords