Stigma and Recruitment for Labor Market Assistance Programs
How to cite
Osman, Adam; Speer, Jamin. 2020. "Stigma and Recruitment for Labor Market Assistance Programs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006131. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6131-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Aversion to “stigma” may contribute to low utilization of social programs, but empirical evidence of its importance is scarce. We use three randomized experiments focused on delivering labor market support to young people to test whether stigma can affect real life decisions. The first experiment recruits to a job training program using street-level marketing. The second experiment recruits unemployed youth to the same program via Facebook advertising.The third recruits for a job fair using door-to-door outreach. We randomize the recruitment message used and consider the information's effect on application and attendance rates, as well as selection on those who apply/attend.
Intervention
Our interventions are information messages used to recruit people to participate in labor market support programs. In the first two experiments we give people in the control group information about the program and in the treatment arms we provide additional information from prior graduates about how the program was helpful to them. In the third experiment we give people in the control information about an upcoming job fair and in one treatment arm we recognize the stigma associated with some of the jobs, and in a a second treatment are we try to dispel it.
Experimental design
Our first experiment used in-person, street-level marketing in different areas of Cairo. Young adults were approached on the street by a surveyor and asked if they were interested in hearing about a training program being offered for youth interested in finding jobs. If they answered yes, basic eligibility information was collected. If the person was eligible for the training program (as defined by the NGO), more information was collected and they received a randomized recruitment pitch from the surveyor. We gave pitches aimed at professional, personal and social stigma. Individuals in the control arm were given information about the program's purpose, location, timing, etc. They were also provided information about the income of individuals who graduated 1 year and 5 years ago. Those in the stigma treatment groups got the same information plus text that was almost identical to experiment 1
Experiment 2 was run on Facebook in late 2018. We tested three main ads. The control ad simply informed people about the training program, including the content, length, and format. We then adjusted the control ad to include additional information about ``social stigma'' and ``professional stigma''. In both cases, we collected testimonials from previous graduates of the training program that described how the types of stigma we thought people would be worried about were in fact not as important as the potential job-seekers may have thought.
In Experiment 3, we implemented a door-to-door information campaign in December 2019 that aimed to encourage people to attend a upcoming free job fair. The process was similar to the street-level recruitment in Experiment 1. Surveyors would go from apartment to apartment, asking if there was anyone in the household who was looking for a job. If yes, they would check to see if that individual was in the same age range as the training (18 to 35). They would then collect some basic demographic information and read a randomized informational message about the job fair.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.