When Contact Changes Minds: An Experiment on Transmission of Support for Gay Equality

How to cite

LaCour, Michael. 2015. "When Contact Changes Minds: An Experiment on Transmission of Support for Gay Equality." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000611. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.611-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Michael LaCour*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000611
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.611-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2013-05-29 – 2014-03-31
Countries
United States of America (California)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/611

Abstract

Can a single conversation change minds on divisive social issues, such as
same-sex marriage? A randomized placebo-controlled trial assessed whether gay (N=22)
or straight (N=19) messengers were effective at encouraging voters (N=972) to support
same-sex marriage and whether attitude change persisted and spread to others in voters’
social networks. The results, measured by an unrelated panel survey, show that both
gay and straight canvassers produced large effects initially, but only gay canvassers’ effects
persisted in three-week, six-week, and nine-month follow-ups. We also find strong
evidence of within-household transmission of opinion change, but only in the wake of
conversations with gay canvassers. Contact with gay canvassers further caused substantial
change in ratings of gay men and lesbians more generally. These large, persistent,
and contagious effects are confirmed by a follow-up experiment. Contact with minorities
coupled with discussion of issues pertinent to them is capable of producing a cascade of
opinion change.

Intervention

Registered voters who had previously been enrolled in an Internet panel survey were
contacted at their doorstep by canvassers. Random assignment determined whether contact was initiated
by a gay or straight canvasser and whether the canvasser discussed the subject of same-sex
marriage or recycling. Outcomes were assessed unobtrusively by online surveys conducted days,
weeks, and months afterward. Canvassers were coached to be polite and respectful at all times, to listen attentively
to voters when discussing either same-sex marriage or recycling, and to refrain from arguing with
voters. The
same-sex marriage script invited voters to share their experiences with marriage. This script was the
same for gay and straight canvassers, with one important exception. After establishing rapport with
the voter, midway through the conversation, gay canvassers revealed that they are gay or lesbian and
that they would like to get married but that the law prohibits same-sex marriage. Straight canvassers
instead described how their child, friend, or relative would like to get married but that the law prohibits
same-sex marriage. Voters were asked to share their thoughts on this dilemma. These doorstep
conversations lasted on average 22 minutes.

Experimental design

Registered voters who had previously been enrolled in an Internet panel survey were
contacted at their doorstep by canvassers. Random assignment determined whether contact was initiated
by a gay or straight canvasser and whether the canvasser discussed the subject of same-sex
marriage or recycling. Outcomes were assessed unobtrusively by online surveys conducted days,
weeks, and months afterward.

Design details

Randomization method
Households in which at least two registered voters completed the first wave of the on-line panel survey (May 29-30, 2013) were randomly assigned to five experimental conditions. Simple random assignment occurred at the household level to facilitate the analysis of within-household spillovers discussed below. The first group was assigned to receive the same-sex marriage script from a gay canvasser. The second group was assigned to receive the same-sex marriage script from a straight canvasser. Groups three and four were encouraged to recycle household waste by gay or straight canvassers, respectively; however, canvassers did not reveal their sexual orientation when delivering the recycling script. The fifth group was a control group to which no canvassers were assigned.
Randomization unit
Simple random assignment occurred at the household level to facilitate the analysis of within-household spillovers discussed below.
Clusters
3532 unique households
Observations
9,507 panelists interviewed over 7 waves, consisting of 59,207 survey interviews (with survey attrition).
Arms
1943 households (HH) control (no canvassing contact), 423 households same-sex marriage message by gay canvasser, 385 households same-sex marriage message by straight canvasser, 389 households placebo recycling message by gay canvassers, 392 households placebo recycling message by straight canvassers
Primary outcomes
Before canvassers went into the field, the study first gathered baseline positions on a range of political attitudes for all participants using an ostensibly unrelated online survey. The survey included 50 questions, as described in the Supplemental Online Materials (SOM). The two questions concerning same-sex marriage and feelings about gay people were buried amid a large number of items on unrelated topics so that respondents would not suspect any connection between the survey and the canvassing visit. The panel survey included the two outcome measures in every wave, but the overall content of the survey was kept fresh by randomly rotating new questions in each wave. Another important feature of the design concerns blinding of canvassers and survey respondents. Voters were unaware that the online survey was related to the canvassing effort, and canvassers had no knowledge that voters were participants in an online survey. Finally, to prevent housemates from completing each other’s surveys, extensive precautions were taken, including issuing distinct personal login instructions to take differently named surveys, tracking of distinct IP addresses and session cookies, and sending invitations to take the survey during working hours (91% were in fact completed at work), when housemates would be less likely to be together.

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. LaCour, Michael J. & Donald P. Green. “When Contact Changes Minds: An Experiment on Transmission of Support For Gay Equality”, Science, 12 December 2014: 346 (6215), 1366-1369. http://www.sciencemag.org/content/346/6215/1366

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords