Consumer Loan Flexibility

How to cite

Hall, Joseph; Kanz, Martin; Fiorin, Stefano. 2020. "Consumer Loan Flexibility." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0006109. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6109-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Joseph Hall* , Martin Kanz , Stefano Fiorin

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0006109
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.6109-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2020-07-06 – 2022-04-05
Countries
India ()
JEL codes
Household Finance, Household Saving, Personal Finance, Non-Bank Financial Institutions, Marketing & Advertising
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/6109

Abstract

We are testing the effectiveness of offering payment flexibility to consumer borrowers in India during the COVID-19 crisis. We test whether offering late-paying borrowers who have taken out loans to purchase smartphones in India an additional 3 months to repay their loan improves the performance of the loans, how it affects borrowers’ perceptions of the lender, and their willingness to do repeat business with the lender.

Intervention

EXPERIMENT 1

Late-paying borrowers who have taken out loans to purchase smartphones in India receive phone calls from the lender and are made different offers. Some borrowers are offered a 3 months moratorium on their loan in exchange for a small fee. They are told that the offer is an initiative of the lender to help struggling borrowers. Other borrowers are made an identical 3 months moratorium offer, but are told that the offer is made as a result of a new directives from the central bank. Finally, other borrowers are not made any flexibility offer, and receive instead either a debt-collection call or a placebo check-in call.

Borrowers receive phone calls with varying content.

Treatment 1A contains an offer for a 3-month payment holiday on their loan, accompanied by messaging explaining that the offer made is because the company cares for its customers.

Treatment 1B contains an offer for a 3-month payment holiday on their loan, accompanied by messaging explaining that the offer is made because the regulators have encouraged all lenders to extend such offers.

Treatment 1C/Placebo contains no offer, but rather a friendly check-in call directing the borrower to informational resources.

Treatment 1D/Control contains no offer, but rather a request for repayment of the loan, as the lender would do in this situation typically.

EXPERIMENT 2
Participants from treatments 1A and 1B of experiment 1 participate in a second experiment, and are cross-randomized in four conditions. They receive a phone call from the lender and are made different offers. In the first dimension of randomization, some borrowers are offered another loan, while others are offered a non-credit product (“enhanced credit report”). In the second dimension of randomization, some offers are “branded” (mention the name of the lender), while other offers non-branded (do not mention the name of the lender).

Participants from treatments 1A and 1B of experiment 1 receive phone calls with varying content.

Treatment 2A contains an offer for a branded loan.

Treatment 2B contains an offer for a non-branded loan.

Treatment 2C contains an offer for a branded report.

Treatment 2D contains an offer for a non-branded report.

Experimental design

EXPERIMENT 1

Borrowers receive phone calls with varying content.

Treatment 1A contains an offer for a 3-month payment holiday on their loan, accompanied by messaging explaining that the offer made is because the company cares for its customers.

Treatment 1B contains an offer for a 3-month payment holiday on their loan, accompanied by messaging explaining that the offer is made because the regulators have encouraged all lenders to extend such offers.

Treatment 1C/Placebo contains no offer, but rather a friendly check-in call directing the borrower to informational resources.

Treatment 1D/Control contains no offer, but rather a request for repayment of the loan, as the lender would do in this situation typically.

EXPERIMENT 2

Participants from treatments 1A and 1B of experiment 1 receive phone calls with varying content.

Treatment 2A contains an offer for a branded loan.

Treatment 2B contains an offer for a non-branded loan.

Treatment 2C contains an offer for a branded report.

Treatment 2D contains an offer for a non-branded report.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomized by computer.
Randomization unit
Individual-level randomization.
Clusters
Experiment 1: 9.623 individuals Experiment 2: 1,160 individuals
Observations
Experiment 1: 9.623 individuals Experiment 2: 1,160 individuals
Arms
Experiment 1: 1,901 in Treatment A 1,829 in Treatment B 2,452 in Treatment C/Placebo 3,441 in Treatment D/Control Experiment 2 134 in 1A-Treatment 2A branded loan. 133 in 1B-Treatment 2A branded loan. 136 in 1A-Treatment 2B non-branded loan. 124 in 1B-Treatment 2B non-branded loan. 143 in 1A-Treatment 2C branded report. 161 in 1B-Treatment 2C branded report. 159 in 1A-Treatment 2D non-branded report. 169 in 1B-Treatment 2D non-branded report.
Primary outcomes
There are three key outcome variables. Outcome 1: Responses to surveys. We will survey borrowers to ask about their perceptions of the lender, the government, and the marketplace. Outcome 2: Long-term repayment rate of loans. Outcome 3: Willingness of borrowers to do repeat business with the lender.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords