Does the support for behavioral policies depend on why they work? Representative evidence on the relevance of psychological mechanisms

How to cite

Werner, Katharina; Lergetporer, Philipp; Grewenig, Elisabeth; Fischer, Mira. 2020. "Does the support for behavioral policies depend on why they work? Representative evidence on the relevance of psychological mechanisms." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005965. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5965-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Katharina Werner* , Philipp Lergetporer , Elisabeth Grewenig , Mira Fischer

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005965
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5965-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-06-03 – 2021-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5965

Abstract

In this project, we investigate whether people’s support of a behavioral policy depends on the psychological mechanism by which it affects behavior. We implement an online-survey experiment among a representative sample of adults aged 18 to 69 years in Germany. Each subject is randomly assigned to one of ten experimental groups, and completes three consecutive stages. In stage 1 all subjects are asked whether they support training for the unemployed. In stage 2 all subjects are presented with a vignette of an unemployed individual, who is informed by letter that the Federal Employment Agency registered him for a training course and that he has two weeks to object to his registration, and is otherwise obliged to participate. Depending on the treatment, subjects learn in the vignette that he participated in the training with (i) no further information given to the subjects, (ii) because he did not read the letter and hence did not know that he could opt out, (iii) because he thought due to his registration that the training would help him to find a new job faster, (iv) because he felt socially pressured to participate in the training, (v) with no further information, except that the individual was undecided whether to participate, (vi) because he did not know that he could opt out and that he was undecided whether to participate, (vii) because he did not know that he could opt out due to no fault of his own and that he was undecided whether to participate, (viii) because he thought due to his registration that the training would help him to find a new job faster and that he was undecided whether to participate, (ix) because he felt socially pressured to participate in the training and that he was undecided whether to participate, (x) or because he felt socially pressured to participate since he thought society would expect him to and that he was undecided whether to participate. All subjects are then asked to report their level of agreement with the described procedure. Stage 3 elicits subjects’ beliefs about whether the procedure (i) restricts the freedom of those that are unemployed, (ii) influences the beliefs about the effectiveness of the course for finding employment, (iii) exerts social pressure on those that are unemployed, (iv) increases the chances of unemployed to find back into paid employment, and (v) is welfare-enhancing for the unemployed.

Intervention

We investigate whether people’s support of a behavioral policy depends on the psychological mechanism by which it affects behavior. Subjects complete a questionnaire on (i) their support for further training for the unemployed (ii) their support for an automatic registration for further training for the unemployed with the possibility to opt out presented to them in a vignette, and (iii) their beliefs about the importance of different psychological mechanisms for the effectiveness of the behavioral policy and their evaluation of the policy. Depending on the treatment, subjects learn in the vignette that an unemployed individual participated in the training (i) with no further explanation given to the subjects, (ii) because he did not read the letter and hence did not know that he could opt out, (iii) because he thought due to his registration that the training would help him to find a new job faster, (iv) because he felt socially pressured to participate in the training, (v) with no further information, except that the individual was undecided whether to participate, (vi) because he did not know that he could opt out and that he was undecided whether to participate, (vii) because he did not know that he could opt out due to no fault of his own and that he was undecided whether to participate, (viii) because he thought due to his registration that the training would help him to find a new job faster and that he was undecided whether to participate, (ix) because he felt socially pressured to participate in the training and that he was undecided whether to participate, (x) or because he felt socially pressured to participate since he thought society would expect him to and that he was undecided whether to participate.
The treatment variation allows us to study whether respondents’ beliefs about how a nudge affects decision-making affects their support for a behavioral policy.

Experimental design

We conduct the experiment in a sample of 10,000 adults aged between 18 and 69 years. The survey is conducted in cooperation with respondi. The recruitment and polling is managed by respondi, who collect the data via an online platform. That is, our participants answer the survey questions autonomously on their own digital devices. Randomization is carried out by respondi at the individual level, using a computer.

Our experiment is structured as follows:
Treatment 1a:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, no information on decision-making by the unemployed is given
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 2a:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed does not know about the default rule
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 3a:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed interprets the default as containing positive information about the effectiveness of the object of the default
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 4a:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed feels socially pressured by the default
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 1b:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed is ex-ante indifferent
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 2b:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed does not know about the default rule and that he is ex-ante indifferent
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 2b’:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed does not know about the default rule due to no fault of his own, and that he is ex-ante indifferent
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 3b:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed interprets the default as containing positive information about the effectiveness of the object of the default and that he is ex-ante indifferent
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 4b:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed feels socially pressured by the default and that he is ex-ante indifferent
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Treatment 4b’:
Stage 1: Question on baseline level of support for training for the unemployed
Stage 2: Vignette to measure support for default rule, information that the unemployed feels socially pressured by the default, that he believes the default to be expected by society and that he is ex-ante indifferent
Stage 3: Questionnaire to measure beliefs about the psychological mechanisms relevant for decision making and evaluation of the policy

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is carried out by the survey company respondi, using a computer.
Randomization unit
at the individual level
Clusters
10,000 adults aged 18-69 years
Observations
10,000 adults aged 18-69 years
Arms
approx. 1,000 will be assigned to each of the Treatment groups
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcomes of interest are subjects’ support for a behavioural policy.
Secondary outcomes
Heterogeneity by baseline level of support for training of the unemployed

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords