Impacts of Information through Text Messages, Voice Recordings, and Phone calls on False Beliefs during the Covid-19 Crisis

How to cite

D, Sadish; Nyshadham, Anant; Adhvaryu, Achyuta. 2020. "Impacts of Information through Text Messages, Voice Recordings, and Phone calls on False Beliefs during the Covid-19 Crisis." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005947. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5947-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sadish D* , Anant Nyshadham , Achyuta Adhvaryu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005947
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5947-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-06-16 – 2020-08-15
Countries
India ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5947

Abstract

We will randomize study subjects to receive information on Covid-19 through one of three modes: text messages, voice recordings, and phone calls. We will compare the three groups to see which method causes the largest change in beliefs, and whether these effects are moderated by short-term memory.

Intervention

We will randomize study subjects to receive information on Covid-19 through one of three modes: text messages, voice recordings, and phone calls. The content of the message will remain unchanged for all interventions.

Experimental design

We will run a randomized controlled experiment where we randomly choose whether a study subject receives information relevant to the Covid-19 pandemic in one of three modes: text message, voice recording, or phone call. The content of the message will remain constant for all three modes.

Subjects: The subjects are current and former garment factory employees in India who are internal migrants of Odiya origin.

Stratified Randomization: We will group subjects into strata, and randomize individuals within strata. Each strata will indicate a unique combination of the at least following four binary or categorical variables:
1. Whether a subject is female
2. Whether a subject is highly educated
3. Whether a subject has left their job
4. The factory of employment

Measures: We will measure the following constructs in addition to the outcomes:

Short-Term Memory: The longest sequence of one-digit numbers an individual can recall within 5 seconds of hearing it. This variable will be measured before the intervention, but not after.

Numeracy: A sum of three binary variables that indicate whether an individual can solve simple addition, subtraction, and multiplication problems mentally. This variable will be measured before the intervention, but not after.

Hypotheses: We will test the following hypotheses:

1. Beliefs Index will be higher for subjects treated with voice recordings compared to subjects treated with text messages.
2. Beliefs Index will be higher for subjects treated with phone calls compared to subjects treated with text messages.
3. Beliefs Index will be higher for subjects treated with phone calls compared to subjects treated with voice recordings.
4. The difference in Beliefs Index between subjects treated with either voice recordings or phone calls compared to subjects treated with text messages will be positive, and larger for individuals with higher short-term memory.
5. The difference in Beliefs Index between subjects treated with either voice recordings or phone calls compared to subjects treated with text messages will be the same for individuals regardless of their numeracy.
6. The difference in the Depression Index between subjects treated with voice recordings compared to subjects treated with text messages will be zero.
7. The difference in the Depression Index between subjects treated with phone calls compared to subjects treated with text messages will be zero.
8. The difference in the Depression Index between subjects treated with phone calls compared to subjects treated with voice recordings will be zero.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomizaiton using a computer program
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
.
Observations
We plan to include a minimum of 750 individuals in the study. We plan to collect survey data for each individual once before the intervention, and once after.
Arms
We will divide the subjects in the ratio 2:2:1 to receive phone calls, voice recordings, and text messages respectively. Sample size calculations for the Beliefs Index assume: 1. Probability of Type-I error: 0.05 2. Probability of Type-II error: 0.2 3. One pre-intervention and one post-intervention measure of outcome 4. A correlation of 0.75 between outcome measurements before and after intervention. 5. ANCOVA specification 6. The same standard deviation for all treatment groups With about 425 subjects, we are powered to detect a minimum effect of 20 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving phone calls and that receiving voice recordings, and a minimum effect of 25 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving text message, and either of the other groups. With about 750 subjects, we are powered to detect a minimum effect of 15 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving phone calls and that receiving voice recordings, and a minimum effect of 20 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving text message, and either of the other groups. For the Mental Health index, we assume a correlation of 0.55 between outcome measurements before and after intervention. Then, with about 450 subjects, we are powered to detect a minimum effect of 25 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving phone calls and that receiving voice recordings, and a minimum effect of 30 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving text message, and either of the other groups. With about 750 subjects, we are powered to detect a minimum effect of 20 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving phone calls and that receiving voice recordings, and a minimum effect of 25 percent of standard deviation between the group receiving text message, and either of the other groups.
Primary outcomes
1. Beliefs Index 2. Mental Health Index (PHQ8)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords