The endogeneity of moral assessments
How to cite
Lergetporer, Philipp; Werner, Katharina; Grewenig, Elisabeth. 2020. "The endogeneity of moral assessments." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005942. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5942-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this project, we investigate the extent to which people manipulate their views on morality in a self-serving way. We implement an online experiment among a representative sample of adults aged between 18 and 69 years in Germany. Each subject is randomly assigned to one of four experimental groups, and completes four consecutive stages. In stage 1 of treatment 1, the subject divides a fixed monetary endowment between herself and a charity which supports children with low educational success. In stage 2, the subject is asked whether she considers it a moral obligation to support children with low educational success. In stage 3, we elicit the subject’s belief about other respondents’ moral assessment and incentivize correct beliefs. In stage 4, we again elicit moral assessment as in stage 2, and pay an incentive if the respondent gives the modal answer among all other respondents. Treatment 2 is identical except for the fact that the allocation task in stage 1 is between other survey participants (instead of the subject herself) and the charity. By comparing responses in stages 2 to 4 between treatments 1 and 2, we assess whether moral assessments and beliefs change to justify previous selfish choices. Treatment 3 is identical to treatment 1 except that there is no allocation decision in stage 1. Instead, subjects are simply informed that they receive an extra payment. Comparing stages 2 to 4 between treatment 1 and treatment 3 allows us to test for endowment effects. Treatment 4 is identical to treatment 1, except that the allocation task is performed in stage 4 instead of stage 1. Comparing allocation decisions between treatment 1 and 4 allow us to investigate the extent to which allocation decisions are affected by preceding (moral) introspection. At the same time, responses in stages 1 to 3 of treatment 3 provide a benchmark for moral assessments which is uncontaminated by preceding allocation decisions.
Intervention
We investigate whether people manipulate moral assessments to justify self-serving behavior. Subjects complete three questions (one unincentivized, two incentivized) on the morality and fairness of supporting children with low educational success. Depending on the treatment (treatment 1 or treatment 2), subjects play one of two versions of a dictator game prior to answering the questions. The receiver in the dictator game is a charity supporting children with low educational success, and the two treatments differ in the extent to which the dictator game allows selfish allocations. The design enables us to study the endogeneity of morality views and beliefs with respect to previous actions. In treatment 3, subjects do not take an allocation decision in stage 1, but they are rather informed that they receive an extra payment. Comparing treatments 1 and 3 allows us to assess the presence of endowment effects. In a fourth treatment, subjects first complete the questions and only then play the dictator game where they allocate an endowment between themselves and the charity. This treatment allows us to study the reverse channel, namely the endogeneity of dictator-game giving with respect to prior (moral) introspection.
Experimental design
We conduct the experiment in a sample of 4,000 adults aged between 18 and 69 years. The survey is conducted in cooperation with the survey institute responi. The recruitment and polling is managed by respondi, who collect the data via an online platform. That is, our participants answer the survey questions autonomously on their own digital devices. Randomization is carried out by respondi at the individual level, using a computer.
Our experiment is structured as follows:
Respondents will be randomly assigned (between subject) to treatment 1 (p=1/4), treatment 2 (p=1/4), treatment 3 (p=1/4), or treatment 4 (p=1/4).
Treatment 1:
Stage 1: Dictator game (oneself versus charity).
Stage 2: Question on morality.
Stage 3: Beliefs about others’ moral assessment.
Stage 4: Question on morality with incentives to provide modal answer.
Treatment 2:
Stage 1: Dictator game (other participants versus charity).
Stage 2: Question on morality.
Stage 3: Beliefs about others’ moral assessment.
Stage 4: Question on morality with incentives to provide modal answer.
Treatment 3:
Stage 1: Information about additional endowment (no allocation decision).
Stage 2: Question on morality.
Stage 3: Beliefs about others’ moral assessment.
Stage 4: Question on morality with incentives to provide modal answer.
Treatment 4:
Stage 1: Question on morality.
Stage 2: Beliefs about others’ moral assessment.
Stage 3: Question on morality with incentives to provide modal answer.
Stage 4: Dictator game (oneself versus charity).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.