Social investment in practice: The evaluation of RELIANCE, an intensive experimental programme to support the return to work of single parents on long-term welfare in France

How to cite

Heim, Arthur. 2020. "Social investment in practice: The evaluation of RELIANCE, an intensive experimental programme to support the return to work of single parents on long-term welfare in France." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005930. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5930-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Arthur Heim*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005930
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5930-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2017-10-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I38, J68, J64
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5930

Abstract

In France, the Active Solidarity Allowance (Revenu de solidarité active/ Rsa) is the main minimum income scheme since 2008. Although it has been modified in 2016, its core features remain a minimum allowance for people with no revenue (Approx € 550/month for a single person), and a supplement to labour income aiming at reducing disincentives to job search by lowering the marginal tax rate to 62\% instead of 100%. In theory, beneficiaries should be provided with personalized support by social workers which take the form of a signed personalized «return to employment» plan or «social reintegration» contract. The nature, intensity and content of these contracts vary a lot between localities and depend on the beneficiaries situation, needs and project, but it is an obligation. Non-participation may lead to reductions or suspension of benefits.

We are interested in assessing the impacts of a pilot welfare-to-work program implemented in France from 2017 to 2021: Reliance, targeting single-parents who have been on welfare for more than 2 years in the urban are of Nancy, in the North-East of France.
The general objective of the project is to set up an action to reintegrate into employment a population that is permanently anchored in the Active Solidarity Income, with very low prospects of returning to work, real or perceived, given their responsibility as single parents.
It concerns a target public residing in the Nancy metropolitan area, an urban and dense territory with public transport and a network of diversified local services such as childcare.
This program is very different from the usual social support provided to Rsa-beneficiaries. it involves 3 social worker working full time for approximately 100 beneficiaries, which is about 10 times smaller than the usual amount of beneficiaries per social worker.
Our research designed is an encouragement design where half of our sample is invited to participate to Reliance while the other is left as a control group and does not know it is being observed in administrative data. The pilot include 3 cohorts (2018-2020).
The data comes from administrative registries of family benefit allowance and surveys collected 2 years after the end of the program.

Intervention

The RELIANCE action is led by an association named Arélia in partnership with two others: the Ulis and Ecoval associations. It consists in supporting heads of single-parent families who are RSA beneficiaries and help them reaching sustainable employment in the Nancy Metropolitan area. Each year of the project (2018-2020) sees about 100 participants, with an objective of about 300 beneficiaries at the end of the pilot. The resources of the services and know-how of the 3 associative partners are mobilized in the fields of:

- professional integration: construction, validation of the professional project, training, job tests, evaluations and internships, access to available aid and entitlements, to the resource bank, refresher courses,
- support for parenting and finding answers to custody arrangements,
- exchange networks, mobility.

In addition, the public is supported, backed and encouraged by collective activities and individual coaching, carried by a team of qualified and experienced professionals.

The objective of the support is therefore:

- the development of the person's autonomy in order to carry out the professional integration procedures,
- access to employment through the implementation of career stages adapted to the individual, taken into account as a whole,
- access to training
- social integration (access to social and medical rights, housing, support for parenthood, strengthening of social ties).

The objective for the project is to reach at least 25 \% positive exit to employment, that is: sustainable employment (permanent or fixed-term contracts or temporary assignments of more than six months, business creation or takeover, internship or integration into the civil service), transitional employment (fixed-term contracts or temporary assignments of less than six months and subsidized contracts), positive departures (training, hiring in a SIAE, and other departures recognized as positive).

Arelia's permanent team consists of 4.5 full-time equivalents (FTEs):
- 1 administrative officer (1 FTE)
- a project team leader (0.5 fte)
- 3 social workers (3 fte)

Arelia will be the sole referent for the beneficiaries.

The Reliance scheme has premises in Vandœuvre, close to public transport. In addition to the reception and offices, the premises include two play areas for children, as well as a changing room and a dining area where children can be looked after collectively while waiting to find permanent childcare facilities.

Experimental design

Each year, a sample of 500 beneficiaries is randomly selected from the administrative databases of the departmental council among households that satisfy the eligibility criteria (single parent less than 50 year-old on welfare for more than 2 years). Each file is examined by the territorial integration referents in order to identify those already in training who would therefore not be available for the programme. Each year, approximately 100 families are removed from this initial sample.

The remaining sample (± 400 beneficiaries) is then randomly assigned to "encouragement" and "control" with a block-design according to the variables number of children (1, 2, 3 and +), seniority in RSA (2 to 5 years, 5 to 10, + 10 years) and enrolment in a job centre.

The encouraged group is then contacted to take part in an information meeting by mail and phone follow-up carried out by the CAF of Meurthe-et-Moselle and the RELIANCE team.

The experiment started in early 2018 and concerns 3 experimental cohorts. Each of them participates for a full year to the program although they can leave earlier if they find a job. If the job ends during the period, they can come back to Reliance until the end of the year.

Design details

Randomization method
Encouragement design with blocking according to the variables number of children (1, 2, 3 and +), seniority in RSA (2 to 5 years, 5 to 10, + 10 years) and enrolment in a job centre. The implementation of the randomization was done using Stata by the principal research officer, with fixed seeds for replication.
Randomization unit
Unit of randomization is individuals within blocks, within cohorts. There are no clusters
Clusters
1200
Observations
1200
Arms
600
Primary outcomes
- Registration of Labor income within 3 years since randomization - Exit of RSA - Entry in PPA - Long term employment (more than 6 months with labour outcome) - Amount of all transfers received from the Family benefit allowance - Subjective well-being based on items from validated research questionnaires. - A self-assessment of health status - A self-assessment of living conditions
Sponsors
Name: Caisse nationale des allocations familliales Url: http://www.caf.fr/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords