Influenza Vaccine: the combined influence of preferences and information about risks and benefits
How to cite
Balmer, Jonas; Biroli, Pietro. 2020. "Influenza Vaccine: the combined influence of preferences and information about risks and benefits." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005857. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5857-1.2000000000000002
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Influenza vaccination is important as it can reduce the risk of not only getting, but also spreading influenza. We evaluated how self-reported regret for not having gotten an influenza vaccination depends on individual preferences and information about the importance of vaccines. We run a 3-arm RCT providing either no information, information about the importance of vaccines to reach herd immunity or the possible importance of influenza vaccination regarding COVID-19. The RCT is embedded in a survey conducted on the employees of the University of Zurich, collecting demographic data, self-reported economic preferences, and beliefs about vaccinations and the medical sector.
Intervention
Survey participants in the different treatment groups are presented with written informative text about the potential benefits of flu vaccines.
The text is meant to prime them to have certain considerations in mind when reporting their willingness to get vaccinated.
Specifically, the informative text appears after 2 pages in the survey, and contains the following:
[Herd-Immunity] “According to the BAG, every year between 112’000 and 275’000 people seek medical advice in connection with seasonal influenza in Switzerland. Many people confuse the seasonal influenza with a simple cold. However, the “real” influenza in contrast to the simple cold, can lead to severe complications, such as heart muscle and lung infections. The people who are the most vulnerable to contracting the seasonal influenza and whose health can negatively affect the severity of the infection, are in many cases not healthy enough to get vaccinated. Therefore, they rely on herd immunity.
Vaccinating is the single most effective way to protect people that rely on herd immunity. It is key to have the seasonal influenza vaccination rate as high as possible due to the limited effectiveness of the vaccination. Therefore, it is essential that as many people as possible get vaccinated. According to a study conducted by Spanish scientists, a rate of approximately 85% is needed to protect the ones who rely on herd immunity.
The overall population of the Kanton Zurich has an influenza vaccination rate of approximately 16% which is equal to the vaccination rate of the employees at the University of Zurich. This is surprising, since the employees, in contrast to most of the rest of the population, can get vaccinated for free.”
[COVID-19] “Discussing the potential connection between influenza vaccination and the covid-19 (Coronavirus) pandemic, Dr. Albert Ko, a professor and department chair at the Yale School of Public Health, said the following:
“I do think immunizing people against influenza has a very important indirect effect,"
(https://www.livescience.com/getting-flu-shot-help-coronavirus-outbreak.html)
He further explains that reducing the amount of influenza infections can “relieve pressure” from hospitals also treating patients with covid-19.”
Experimental design
We run a 3-arm Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) providing either no information, or information about the importance of vaccines to reach herd immunity, or the possible importance of influenza vaccination to protect against COVID-19.
The RCT is embedded in an online survey sent to all of the employees of the University of Zurich, collecting demographic data, self-reported economic preferences, and beliefs about vaccinations and the medical sector. Completing the online survey is voluntary.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.