Extending health insurance to the informal sector through microfinance in Nicaragua

How to cite

Thornton, Rebecca; Monada, Martha Gonzalez; Diaz, Freddy Solis; Islam, Mursaleena; Field, Erica; Hatt, Laurel. 2015. "Extending health insurance to the informal sector through microfinance in Nicaragua." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000585. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.585-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rebecca Thornton* , Martha Gonzalez Monada , Freddy Solis Diaz , Mursaleena Islam , Erica Field , Laurel Hatt

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000585
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.585-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2007-01-01 – 2009-09-01
Countries
Nicaragua (Central America)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/585

Abstract

This study presents the results from an experimental evaluation of a voluntary health insurance program for informal sector workers in Nicaragua. Costs of the premiums as well as enrollment location were randomly allocated. Overall, take-up of the program was low, with only 20% enrollment. Program costs and streamlined bureaucratic procedures were important determinants of enrollment. Participation of local microfinance institutions had a slight negative effect on enrollment. One year later, those who received insurance substituted toward services at covered facilities and total out-of-pocket expenditures fell. However, total expenditures fell by less than the insurance premiums. We find no evidence of an increase in health-care utilization among the newly insured. We also find very low retention rates after the expiration of the subsidy, with less than 10% of enrollees still enrolled after one year. To shed light on the findings from the experimental results, we present qualitative evidence of institutional and contextual factors that limited the success of this program.

Intervention

In January 2007, the government of Nicaragua initiated a pilot program that extended the Nicaraguan Social Security Institute’s (INSS’s) health insurance program, which was previously only for formal sector employees, to informal sector workers. The coverage and cost of the program were designed to be as similar as possible to those associated with the program for workers employed in the formal sector. For a flat monthly fee, individuals in the informal sector gained access to a wide range of services with zero co-payment. The cost of the program was structured such that the monthly fee was higher in the first two months, at approximately US$18 per month, and then fell to approximately US$15 per month in subsequent months. The health insurance covered enrolled individuals and dependents under the age of twelve.

This evaluation attempted to measure the determinants of insurance enrollment as well as the impacts of having insurance for informal sector workers by randomly varying the costs and convenience of signing up for INSS health insurance. Individuals were assigned to purchase the insurance at either the INSS central office or the branch office of three participating MFIs: ACODEP, Banco ProCredit, and Findesa.
Between March and June 2007, a few months after the INSS insurance program was rolled out to informal sector workers, a baseline survey was administered to a representative sample of vendors in the three largest open-air markets in central Managua. At the end of the baseline survey, respondents were invited to choose a lottery ticket out of a stack of unmarked, pre-sealed envelopes. The possible lottery prizes included a blank ticket (no prize); an INSS brochure detailing the insurance product; a brochure accompanied by a 6-month insurance subsidy with instructions to sign up at the INSS office; or a brochure accompanied by a 6-month insurance subsidy with instructions to sign up at an MFI office. The 6-month subsidy was worth approximately US$96 and was provided in the form of a voucher; respondents were told that payments would be made on their behalf directly to the INSS. After one year, respondents were then approached for a follow-up survey to measure changes in health and healthcare utilization.

Experimental design

To measure the determinants of insurance enrollment as well as the causal effects of having insurance, we implemented an evaluation that randomly varied the costs (financial, informational, and convenience) of signing up for health insurance for each individual. Data collection involved a baseline and one-year follow-up survey of a sample of eligible participants in addition to consolidated administrative data on insurance affiliation from INSS. The baseline survey collected information in two rounds on demographic characteristics, prior and current health services utilization, socioeconomic characteristics, and health-care expenditures. Government ID numbers were collected to match respondents to health insurance enrollment data subsequently provided by the government. For the follow-up survey, 2807 respondents were approached, and 2610 (93%) were successfully re-interviewed. Our analysis is restricted to the respondents who completed interviews at both baseline and follow-up and had valid voucher data.

Design details

Randomization method
Participants were invited to choose a lottery ticket out of a stack of unmarked, pre-sealed envelopes.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
2,807 respondents
Observations
2,807 respondents
Arms
Pure Control: 119 respondents Treatment groups: - Informational brochure only: 1,200 respondents - Six-month subsidy, enroll at INSS: 758 respondents - Six-month subsidy, enroll at MFI: 730 respondents
Primary outcomes
Take-up of insurance; Impact on utilization and expenditures; Retention.

Papers from this trial

  1. Health Econ. 19: 181–206 (2010) Published online 30 June 2010 in Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/hec.1635 http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/store/10.1002/hec.1635/asset/1635_ftp.pdf;jsessionid=6BFEF4569045D0C59EEE7F1ED08EA33A.f04t04?v=1&t=i4fpplju&s=53121a5f13968d431bf63dd06fe8ab850c35e40c

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords