A Randomized Controlled Trial on the Provision of Financial and Social Capital to Low-Income Households in the United States
How to cite
Jaroszewicz, Ania; Jachimowicz, Jon; Hauser, Oliver; Ashraf, Nava; Bianchi, Emily; Haushofer, Johannes; Meier, Stephan. 2021. "A Randomized Controlled Trial on the Provision of Financial and Social Capital to Low-Income Households in the United States." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005826. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5826-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Prior research, conducted predominantly in low-income countries, has found that unconditional cash transfers can be an effective means of lifting people out of poverty. We propose that financial capital alone may be insufficient to fully address the challenges posed by poverty, which include a lack of belongingness, information, and goal-setting accountability—challenges that may be more adequately addressed through social capital. We hypothesize that the effects of financial and social capital are additive or potentially even multiplicative, such that each form of capital adds to or even enhances the effectiveness of the other. In collaboration with a US-based non-profit organization, we will test these predictions in an 18-month randomized controlled trial. We will randomize approximately 1,800 low-income households in Cambridge and Boston, MA, into one of four treatment arms: financial capital (unconditional cash transfers of $500 per month for 18 months), social capital (encouragement to develop and strengthen social ties), the combination of both the financial and social capital treatments, or no treatment. Using in-depth panel data composed of surveys, administrative bank account data, and administrative welfare receipt data, we not only seek to understand whether the combination of financial and social capital can improve financial, psychological, health, and family well-being outcomes, but also why and for whom they may improve outcomes. Taken together, these data will offer insights into how the combination of financial and social capital can support low-income US households in sustainably moving out of poverty.
Intervention
In this large-scale, longitudinal randomized controlled trial, we aim to understand the extent to which the negative effects of poverty can be ameliorated through financial and social capital support. Approximately 1,800 low-income households in the Boston, MA area will be randomly assigned to either (a) receive a “no-strings-attached” unconditional cash transfer of $500 per month (totaling $9,000 over 18 months), (b) be encouraged to develop their social capital by creating and engaging with a “peer group” of four to eight participating households, (c) receive both the financial assistance and social capital interventions, or (d) not receive any intervention. We will track the households' financial, psychological, physical health, and family well-being outcomes at regular intervals over the 18 month trial. We predict that the provision of financial and social capital alone will each have a significant and positive effect on outcomes, and that the effect of combining financial and social capital will be larger than the effect of providing either financial or social capital alone. We propose that the positive effects of combining the two forms of capital will occur in part because financial and social capital may address different problems of low-income households, and in part because financial and social capital may interact to mutually enhance one another, amplifying the treatment intensity of each.
Experimental design
To be eligible for the trial, households must reside in Cambridge or Boston, MA, and have a total earned household income between 0% and 200% of the federal poverty line. Participants in the Cash-only (hereafter, “C”) treatment arm will receive $9,000 over 18 months in fully unconditional payments, paid out as $500 per month. For a household of four living at the poverty line, these payments will raise participants’ annual earned income by 22%. That is, participants in this arm who earn near the poverty line will receive unconditional payments equal to almost three months of income per year. The Social-only (“S”) arm will be placed into peer groups with three to seven other participants in this treatment arm and will be encouraged to interact with their peer groupmates through monthly meetings. They will also be given access to an online platform that aims to help people develop and strengthen social ties, in part by decreasing barriers to help-seeking and -giving. Finally, they will be given a small unconditional payment of $20 per month. Those in the Cash+Social (“CS”) arm will receive the same financial benefits as the Cash treatment arm and the same social capital benefits as the Social treatment arm. Finally, those in the No Treatment Control (“NTC”) arm will receive only the small unconditional payment ($20 per month) and will not be given any opportunity to participate in any of the social interventions.
We will examine the effects of these treatments on a wide range of outcomes, leveraging panel data and a rich and complementary array of datasets. All participants will be asked to complete quarterly surveys, which will ask about financial, psychological, health, and family well-being outcomes. We will also observe transaction-level financial outcomes from checking and savings accounts, including savings stocks, direct deposits of earned income, and late fees charged. Finally, for participants who are recipients of any welfare program administered by our partner state agency, or who have received benefits in the five years before the trial begins, we will also observe administrative data from that agency. This data will include a comprehensive past and present financial profile, welfare applications and receipts, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefit usage, and employment outcomes, enabling us to verify and complement many survey measures.
The first and most fundamental aim of this study is to quantify the effects of the treatment arms (C, S, and CS), relative to the NTC arm, on our pre-registered outcomes. Specifically, we seek to measure the effects of our treatments on financial (e.g., subjective financial well-being, number of bills left unpaid), psychological (e.g., sense of agency, depression), health (e.g., sleep quality, nutritional quality), and family well-being (e.g., parenting quality, quality of relations with one’s partner) outcomes. Second, we will aim to identify the underlying mechanisms that may drive our treatment effects. To this end, we will examine the roles of both intrapersonal mechanisms (e.g., cognitive capacity, time preferences, risk preferences), as well as interpersonal mechanisms (e.g., sense of support from others, comfort with asking for help, extent to which others are helping one achieve one’s goals). Finally, our study design gives us the opportunity to test whether the treatments work particularly well for specific subpopulations.
Please see the attached preregistration manuscript for more details.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.