Can Asset Transfer & Asset Protection Policies Alter Poverty Dynamics in Northern Kenya?
How to cite
Jensen, Nathan. 2020. "Can Asset Transfer & Asset Protection Policies Alter Poverty Dynamics in Northern Kenya?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005822. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5822-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The pastoralist regions of Northern Kenya have seen a number of interventions intended to address the deep poverty and the extreme vulnerability with which it is intertwined. This research examines two of those interventions that have recently received a great deal of public support and recognition.Index Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) Asset Protection Program, which developed a satellite-based index that triggers payouts to households that experience climatic shocks, allowing them to protect their assets. Rural Entrepreneur Access Project (REAP) Asset Transfer (or Graduation) Program, which transfers and helps poor women build a suite of tangible and intangible (or psychological) assets.
While there is evidence that both programs are individually effective in the short to medium term, the programs have the potential to complement each other and in combination offer a package that fundamentally alters poverty in the region. Having secured the cooperation of the program implementers, the research proposed here will test the efficacy of this package and how best and most cost-effectively to assemble it.The primary objectives of the proposed research are to (1) measure the impact of each of Rural Entrepreneur Access Project (REAP) graduation program and Index Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) on the extent and depth of poverty at the community level in Samburu North in northern Kenya, and (2) compare that to the impacts of a package that combines both interventions.
Intervention
Intervention 1: REAP (Rural Entrepreneur Access Project)
REAP is a two year, graduation-style intervention that was developed and introduced in northern Kenya in 2009 by the non-governmental organization known as the BOMA Project. The REAP program aims to enable poor women graduate from poverty by helping them start sustainable businesses. The program includes financial coaching, business training and seed funds. Eligible women are selected through a rigorous process of initial wealth ranking of each household by community members, followed by household level validation facilitated by BOMA staff. Uniquely, the program facilitates the formation of three-women business groups that are the foundation of each intervention. As of mid 2017, the BOMA project had helped to launch over 5,200 businesses and 830 savings groups which have directly involved over 15,600 women.
Concretely, the graduation program targets the most vulnerable women and helps them to establish a sustainable income and savings through a two-year program of sequenced interventions:
1. Targeting of participants for the development of three-woman business groups;
2. Two years of mentoring;
3. Business skills training;
4. A seed capital jump grant of $US 200 to start the business;
5. Savings group training and a $US 100 progress grant (if the business remains in operation); and,
6. Access to credit through membership in savings groups
Intervention 2: Index Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI)
IBLI has been sold as a commercial insurance product in northern Kenya since 2010. The insurance relies on an NDVI satellite index to measure relative forage availability and make insurance payments when levels are much below normal for that region during that period. The index is calculated at the end of each rainy season and payouts are made when the index indicates forage is likley to be scarce during the following dry season. Since its inception, IBLI has expanded to include seven counties in Kenya and the Borena Zone of Ethiopia. The government of Kenya launched the Kenya Livestock Insurance program (KLIP) in 2015, which purchases IBLI insurance coverage for over 18,000 targeted pastoralists.
Experimental design
This study takes place in Samburu County, Kenya. The sampling and treatment randomization process were developed to integrate well with existing processes used by BOMA. Specifically, BOMA uses a Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) for classifying households in each village into wealth categories. The poorest—usually around 50%--women are then screened for interest and potential barriers to participation. Those that pass the second screening are classified as REAP-eligible. This study samples from the REAP-eligible and the group of women that were placed in the wealth group just above the REAP-eligible threshold by their community, which we call the Vulnerable women.
Using BOMA’s rosters from the study region, half of the REAP-eligible study participants will be allocated into the control group and half will be allocated into the treatment group. This allocation will be stratified by community. Those in the REAP treatment group will then be allocated across five REAP treatment waves, which will be rolled out every 6 months over the first 24 months of the project. This approach aligns with BOMA’s standard operating procedure and will introduce variation in treatment durations and period since graduation, allowing us to use a continuous treatment approach for estimating impacts. Further, we have introduced variation in the distribution of REAP treatments across waves between communities, so that there will be between-community variation in the saturation of REAP businesses during midline, offering insight into spillover effects between businesses.
Insurance will be sold by the private insurance company Takaful Insruacne of Africa, starting in February 2018 and will available to everyone in the study area. Through stratified randomization within wealth group and community, half of study participants (those from the REAP-eligible group and the Vulnerable group) will be allocated into the IBLI-control group and 50% will be allocated into the IBLI treatment group. Within the IBLI treatment group, one third will be allocated into each of the three subsidy schemes. Insurance can be purchased during insurance windows that occur twice each year. Those in control can purchase insurance at the commercial rates. Those in the IBLI treatment arms will receive discount coupons which they can submit to an insurance agent to receive their discount. IBLI policies last for 12 months and overlapping coverage can be purchased.
This research will examine the impacts of insurance coverage and test 3 subsidy schemes for their impact on uptake. One treatment arm will receive a subsidy scheme similar to that employed by KLIP. One insurance subsidy scheme is similar to that offered by KLIP--100% subsidy for the first few animals and zero subsidy for additional animals. The two other IBLI-treated arms will face subsidy schemes that vary in response to the amount of coverage purchased.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.