The impact of prepaid electricity meters on low income households in Cape Town South Africa
How to cite
Jack, B. Kelsey; Smith, Grant. 2014. "The impact of prepaid electricity meters on low income households in Cape Town South Africa." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000582. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.582-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Prepaid water and electricity meters offer a promising solution to lumpy and unpredictable bills by allowing customers to choose the timing and quantity of purchases. At the same time, prepayment circumvents debt accumulation, allowing utility companies to serve otherwise high-cost customers. Researchers will collaborate with the municipal utility in Cape Town, South Africa to evaluate customer responses and revenue recovery for prepaid versus credit electricity metering. The study generates new evidence on the impacts of prepaid meters on energy use and revenue recovery using a randomized phase-in of new prepaid customers. Researchers will explore how prepaid meters change the customer experience and the municipality’s revenue recovery.
Intervention
The City of Cape Town switched approximately 4000 households from credit (post paid) meters to prepaid meters. These households have been identified based on property value. Household meter conversion was involuntary. The meter installation is not accompanied by any additional information about electricity tariffs or consumption.
Experimental design
In collaboration with the researchers, the City will phase in the prepaid meters according to a randomized phase in design. The randomization unit is a block of approximately 200 geographically contiguous households. The resulting blocks are assigned a random order and meter installation proceeds accordingly. Not all meters are installed according to the schedule. “Hold out” households receive meters late, and other households request installation before their randomization block is reached. Thus, compliance with treatment order is imperfect in both directions.
The study timeline is compressed by the demands of the City, which requires all prepaid conversions in Mitchells Plain to be complete by February. Consequently, the lag between the initial phase in block and the final phase in block will be short (~3 months), allowing for only short run impacts to be analyzed with the phase in design.
Analysis of outcomes from the administrative data will be conducted both with treatment assignment on the righthand side (ITT) and with the assigned treatment order as a predictor of actual treatment date (TOT). Using the panel nature of the data to introduce household fixed effects, a difference in difference regression will compare electricity usage outcomes (consumption or expenditure) between credit, newly prepaid and less newly prepaid households before and after the treatment date. Analysis of the survey outcomes will follow a similar design but rather than a continuous treatment timing variable, the survey will assign households to treatment (prepaid) and control (credit): their status at the time of the first survey wave.
Design details
Papers from this trial
- Jack, B.K. and G. Smith, (2016) "CHARGING AHEAD: PREPAID ELECTRICITY METERING IN SOUTH AFRICA," NBER Working Paper w22895. http://www.nber.org/papers/w22895
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.