The Economic Impact of Screening Rural Houses as an Additional Vector Control against Malaria Transmission in Zambia

How to cite

Chisanga, Brian; Bulte, Erwin; Kassie, Menale. 2020. "The Economic Impact of Screening Rural Houses as an Additional Vector Control against Malaria Transmission in Zambia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005809. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5809-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Brian Chisanga* , Erwin Bulte , Menale Kassie

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005809
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5809-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2019-01-03 – 2022-11-15
Countries
Zambia (Nyimba District, Eastern Province)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5809

Abstract

Malaria has been recognized as one of the important health concerns in developing countries, with dire economic consequences particularly in Sub-Sahara Africa. In Zambia, the disease accounted for 2000 deaths in 2016 while its prevalence among children under the age of 5 is as estimated to be as high as 30 percent in some rural parts of the country. In this study we seek to determine the socio-economic impacts of House Screening (HS), a malaria control intervention, which works by covering windows, doors and eaves of rural houses with wire mesh, thus protecting the entire households from mosquito bites. We also explores how to stimulate appropriate household behaviors using loss aversion and knowledge diffusion in order to optimize the outcomes of HS. There are several channels through which malaria impedes economic development. Apart from the immediate debilitating effects of morbidity and mortality, it imposes negative impacts on human capital including low productivity, low income and low educational attainment. Therefore, a study to determine the socio-economic impact of HS is necessary for understanding the full-scale impact of interventions that control malaria such as HS. Furthermore, understanding the cost effectiveness of the house screening intervention as well as the Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA) is essential for public health investment considerations. Behavior of households can have profound effects on the outcomes of malaria control interventions including HS. Behaviors such as hours residents spend indoors and outdoors at night have been considered as important in previous studies. Similarly, behaviors such as closing of doors, windows and maintenance of the house screens may have affects on the outcomes of the HS intervention. Using incentives to stimulate appropriate behavior has been studied in several domains. Incentives and nudges can significantly influence behavior to produce desired outcomes. Particularly, framing of incentives as losses has been observed to produce larger positive effects compared to gains - suggesting that the loss frame motivates behavior to a greater extent than the gain frame does. Furthermore, social networks have been identified as important channels for knowledge diffusion. Hence, diffusion of knowledge about house screening is likely to take place within social networks and this may affect their knowledge, behavior towards malaria prevention and willingness to pay for the technology among those who have not yet received it. This study contributes to the emerging literature on the impact of HS, loss aversion and social networks with potential application to health policies in developing countries

Intervention

The main intervention is house screening which protects entire households against mosquito entry thereby reducing or eliminating mosquito bites and malaria cases. The method involves covering windows, doors and eaves of houses with wire mesh with spaces small enough to prevent the entry of mosquitoes. Treatment households will receive house screens plus a mosquito net also referred to as Long Lasting Insecticide Treated Nets (LLINs), while control households will not receive house screens, however, they will each receive a mosquito net. A sub-intervention is the provision of community mobilisation in selected villages, which will provide awareness information on house screening.

Experimental design

The impact evaluation will take place in Nyimba District in the Eastern Province of Zambia. The main treatment is house screening (Treatment 0), which involves free provision and installation of house screens to treatment households plus a mosquito net. The control households will not receive house screens, however, they will each receive a mosquito net. Treatment will be randomly assigned to 400 households while 400 will be control households. Random assignment will be blocked by rural and urban blocks. The rural/urban block is defined by the distance to the urban center (and urban clinic) -with the rural block being further than the urban. Thus, equal samples will be assigned to the treatment and control groups from each of the two blocks. Community mobilization, will be a sub-treatment (Treatment 1), which involves the creation of awareness on house screening to be assigned to selected villages. A total of 45 villages will be randomly assigned to treatment while 44 will be control villages. To test the loss aversion nudge, 200 households from the treatment group (with house screening) will be randomly assigned to the gain frame (Treatment 2) while the other 200 will be assigned the loss frame (Treatment 3). The study will establish social network links between the treated and control households by exploring distance and friendship ties with the help of a household survey and GIS mapping. Treatment 4 is connectedness of the household. Control households with at least one social network with the treated households are the connected households while those without any networks are the unconnected households.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in an office on a computer i.e. the main random allocation to treatment (400 households) and control (400 households).
Randomization unit
The randomisation unit is the household except for the community mobilisation treatment which will be at village level
Clusters
80 villages
Observations
800 households
Arms
400 treated households; 400 control households
Primary outcomes
• Number of days children were sick with malaria • Number of days adults were sick with malaria • Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALYs) • Total number of days missed work due to malaria • Number of school days absent due to malaria • Household income
Secondary outcomes
• Hours spent indoors at night • Hours spent outdoors at night • Doors kept closed (%) • windows kept closed (%) • Noticed breakages or spaces on screens (%) • Repaired /maintained screens (%) • Sleeping under a mosquito net (%) • Knowledge score on house screening • Knowledge score on malaria prevention behaviour • Willing to adopt house screening • Willing to pay for house screening • Willingness to pay bid amount

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords