The goal of this study is to estimate the effect of deadlines and reminders on firms seeking out credit during an economic downturn due to the Covid-19 outbreak. Credit can be valuable to firms to weather the downturn but its benefits are in the future when the cost to obtain one is borne immediately. Forgetfulness and present-bias might be biases that exacerbate the cost and lead firms to not ever search and request a loan. We will study if treatments involving deadlines and reminders (anticipated and unanticipated) helps firms overcome these biases to search for a loan.
Intervention
In our intervention, we will contact firms to provide them details about the opportunity to apply for a loan from a FinTech lender. The firms in our sample are clients of a FinTech electronic payment processing company that is partnering with a separate FinTech lender. The firms will be informed about the loan opportunity through a concurrent email and SMS messages. To test if forgetfulness and present-bias hinder the search for credit, we will vary the content and timing of the emails and SMS messages: firms will be randomly assigned offers to apply for a loan with different combinations of deadlines and unanticipated and anticipated reminder messages.
Experimental design
Messages with deadlines will state that the firm has one week or one day to access the link to apply for credit. Messages with an unanticipated reminder will receive a reminder to access the link one week after. Messages with an anticipated reminder will also receive a reminder to access the link one week after and will be told in the initial email and SMS messages that they will receive this reminder and on what day they will receive it. In total, our design has eight treatment groups:
1. Control, no messages 2. Loan messages with no deadline, no reminder 3. Loan messages with no deadline, anticipated reminder 4. Loan messages with no deadline, unanticipated reminder 5. Loan messages with 1-week deadline, no reminder 6. Loan messages with 1-week deadline, anticipated reminder 7. Loan messages with 1-week deadline, unanticipated reminder 8. Loan messages with 24-hour deadline, no reminder
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization done by a computer (R script)
Randomization unit
We randomize at the individual firm level (note that outcomes are measured at the firm level) using a simple stratified randomization. There are 70,020 individual firms in our experiment.
We stratify our randomization by four variables:
1. Average monthly electronic sales in the past year, or since the firm registered with the payments processing company if it was within the past year (4 quartiles)
2. Business type (6 categories: Beauty, Clothing, Professionals, Restaurants, Small Retailers and Other)
3. Tax registration status (2 categories: Self-Employed and Limited Company)
4. A proxy for initial impact on sales due to the Covid-19 outbreak as of March 2020. This proxy is defined as above or below the median in the percent difference in sales from February 2020 to March 2020. A third group for this categorical variable is made up of those who had no sales in February 2020 such that the change in sales measure is undefined.
We stratified on these variables since we will test for heterogeneous treatment effects by each of these variables (sales, business type, tax registration status, and how affected they were by Covid- 19). Our stratification includes 144 blocks: 4 (prior sales quartiles) * 2 (tax registration status) * 6 (business types) * 3 (impact on sales from Covid-19 outbreak).
Clusters
70,020 clusters (individual firms).
Observations
70,020
Arms
1. Control, no offer: 327
2. Loan offer with no deadline, no reminder: 10355
3. Loan offer with no deadline, anticipated reminder: 8592
4. Loan offer with no deadline, unanticipated reminder: 10362
5. Loan offer with 1-week deadline, no reminder: 10765
6. Loan offer with 1-week deadline, anticipated reminder: 8104
7. Loan offer with 1-week deadline, unanticipated reminder: 10755
8. Loan offer with 24-hour deadline, no reminder: 10760
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome is a dummy variable indicating whether firms apply for a loan. We will also use this outcome to estimate the model in Ericson (2017) to quantify the relative importance and interaction of different behavioral biases in preventing firms from applying for credit.
Secondary outcomes
Through link tracking, we know the fraction of firms in each treatment group that click the links (but cannot link these back to particular firms within each treatment group). Thus, a secondary outcome will be clicking the link. In addition, for those who log in after clicking the link, the FinTech lender also tracks how much progress firms make in completing the loan application (and these measures we can link to other data on the firms from the FinTech payments provider): 0% complete if after clicking the link they log in but do not fill out general information, and 25%, 50%, or 75% complete if they do not fully complete the loan application but complete a fraction of the application. 100% complete applications are our primary outcome “apply for a loan” above. Dummy variables for each of the four partially complete outcomes (0%, 25%, 50%, 75% complete) will be used as secondary outcomes to explore firms’ behavior in the loan application process.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.