Status Quo Bias and Usage of Financial Products

How to cite

Gine, Xavier; Goldberg, Jessica. 2020. "Status Quo Bias and Usage of Financial Products." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005781. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5781-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Xavier Gine* , Jessica Goldberg

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005781
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5781-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2016-04-01 – 2018-06-30
Countries
Malawi ()
JEL codes
D14, D91, C93, G21, O16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5781

Abstract

We present a sample of savings account holders with three choices: to keep their existing account but incur high fees, to close their existing account and receive the balance, or to open a new account with lower fees and transfer the balance to it. These subjects come from 14 villages in southern Malawi. In 2012, as part of a previous study, they were offered fully subsidized basic savings accounts with a local bank. In 2015, some of those who had opened accounts were randomly chosen to receive a MK 25,000 windfall payment (USD 160 using the 2015 purchasing power parity [PPP] exchange rate. See Brune et al. 2017 for details). This transfer did not have persistent effects on savings or spending, but it did increase the number of transactions that subjects made at the bank branch. The random allocation of these transfers thus created exogenous variation in the experience subjects had in using their accounts.

In 2016, the previous research project concluded and subsidies for monthly account maintenance fees were discontinued. Starting in May 2016, individuals had to pay a monthly maintenance fee that had previously been covered by research funds paid directly to the bank. Concurrently but independently, the bank introduced a new account called the Pafupi account. This account had an opening cost, no monthly fees but charged a withdrawal fee per transaction. Based on the number of transactions that subjects had made between 2012 and May 2016, the Pafupi accounts were less expensive than the original (basic) accounts for everyone in the sample, if their usage patterns continued and they planned to keep the account open for at least another four months.

In March and April 2016, the research team visited study subjects at home and asked them to come to the bank branch to make a decision about their savings accounts. Subjects could keep their existing basic account and start paying monthly fees, could close their basic account, or could transfer their balances to a Pafupi account with the purchase of an ATM card. Although the Pafupi account was cheaper than the basic account given their past usage, the choice was presented in a neutral way.

Intervention

In March and April 2016, the research team visited study subjects at home and asked them to come to the bank branch to make a decision about their savings accounts. Subjects could keep their existing basic account and start paying monthly fees, could close their basic account, or could transfer their balances to a Pafupi account with the purchase of an ATM card. Although the Pafupi account was cheaper than the basic account given their past usage, the choice was presented in a neutral way.

The home visits introduced randomized variation in two dimensions of the decision. First, we varied the amount of a payment for coming to the branch, which was used to lower switching costs and encourage individuals to actively make a decision. Second, we varied the timing of when subjects were asked to visit the branch: some were asked to come within the week but others were asked to come only after a two-week delay. This manipulation assessed whether people would fail to show up at the branch due to forgetfulness or costs of paying attention. Finally, when they did visit the branch, some respondents received an unexpected extra payment, which tested whether liquidity constraints prevented individuals from paying the opening fee and purchasing the ATM card required to open the Pafupi account.

Experimental design

We have five treatment groups: a no-bonus or date group, and four groups who could receive cash for coming to the bank within a designated window.

A final treatment was implemented at the bank branch. Some households were randomly selected to be offered MK 1,500 (USD 8 using the 2016 PPP exchange rate), a larger amount than the promised show-up fee. This amount was enough to pay for the MK 1,300 cost to open the Pafupi account and therefore relaxed a possible liquidity constraint. The offer, however, did not contain any explicit or implicit suggestion about how to use the money. All show-up bonuses were paid in cash before participants were asked about their decisions regarding the accounts.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was conducted by computer and stratified by village and previous treatment assignment.
Randomization unit
Individual account holder
Clusters
N/A
Observations
742 account holders of which we were able to interview 592.
Arms
Of the 594 study participants, 187 did not receive the large transfer in 2015 and the rest did. For the 2016 interventions, the 594 subjects were randomized into treatment arms as follows: 125 without show-up bonus, 81 with 500 MK show-up bonus and immediate window, 147 with 500 MK show-up bonus and delayed window, 78 with 1000 MK show-up bonus and immediate window, 163 with 1000 MK show-up bonus and delayed window.
Primary outcomes
Opening of Pafupi account;
Secondary outcomes
Visit to Bank to make decision about current account

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords