We conduct an online survey-experiment in Poland using online platform opinie.pl among voting-age Poles, in which we present to randomly drawn subsets of survey respondents two different information treatments (leaving a control group without any information treatment). The information treatments are comprised of publicly available information from the Polish independent media. The first treatment informs respondents about the cases of pedophilia in the Catholic Church and the second treatment informs respondents about the relationship between the Catholic Church and the PiS (Law and Justice) party, which is currently in power. We will analyze how these messages of the independent media affect the political support for the ruling party and trust in and adherence to the Catholic Church in Poland. Most importantly, we are interested in how pre-existing convictions (such as religiosity and political conservatism) influence these effects. The survey-experiment will complement analysis that we will conduct using observational municipality-level data, which do not allow studying individual heterogeneity in reacting to information messages beyond the highly criticized method of ecological inference. The survey-experiment will allow us to collect individual-level data suitable to study the heterogenous effects across respondents depending on their individual characteristics, such as prior cultural background (e.g., religiosity), political alignment, and media access.
Intervention
The intervention consists of providing information to the subjects using the opinie.pl platform of IQS (or its mobile application). We expose a randomly drawn subsets of subjects to several pieces of publicly available information from the independent Polish media about the pedophilia cases within the Catholic Church and the relationship between the Church and the ruling party, Law and Justice (PiS). Participants will be randomly allocated among 3 groups: (i) Control, (ii) Treatment 1, and (iii) Treatment 2. The two treatments will focus on two different aspects of the message of independent Polish media: exposing pedophilia cases in the Catholic Church and exposing the mutual support between the Catholic Church and the ruling PiS party.
Experimental design
Participants will be allocated randomly into one of the following 3 groups: (i) Control, (ii) Treatment 1, and (iii) Treatment 2. Both treatments consist of exposing respondents to several news articles and videos from the Polish mainstream media. All participants will fill out surveys before and after the treatment which will be used to estimate the treatment effects.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization done in the office of the survey company by a computer.
Randomization unit
We perform stratified randomization across individuals. We randomly assign one third of individuals in each strata (24 in total), defined by gender (2 groups) x age brackets (4 groups) x education levels (3 groups), into the control group, treatment 1, and treatment 2.
1. Trust in the Catholic Church and religiosity levels, measured by:
• Whether respondents chose to donate money to a religious or non-religious foundation (first round);
• The frequency of mass attendance during the last month (follow-up);
• Whether respondents are likely to go to Church every week in the future (follow-up);
• How respondents describe their faith, i.e., believer following the Church recommendations, believer not always following the Church recommendations, non-believer (follow-up);
• Trust in the Catholic Church, priests in their parish, episcopate, the Pope (both rounds).
2. Political support of PiS party and political preferences:
• Voting intention in the next presidential election, which may take place in May (because of COVID-19 crisis, we still do not know if the elections will be held and when) (first round);
• Whom they voted for in the election (if it takes place), or whom they would vote for if the elections were to be held next Sunday (if the election doesn't take place) (follow-up);
• The expected and actual turnout (first and follow-up rounds, respectively);
• Feeling thermometer toward political parties (both rounds);
• Trust in government, Sejm (lower house of the parliament), Senate (upper house of the parliament), president (both rounds).
Secondary outcomes
Auxiliary outcomes:
1. Measuring whether treatments affected respondents' opinions about issues covered in the treatments:
• Opinion about whether a mutual support between the ruling party and the Church is admissible (first round);
• Opinion about the involvement of the Catholic Church in public life and political process (first round);
• Opinions about whether the lessons of religion should take place at school or parish premises and who should pay for them (first round);
• Opinion about the financial support of the state to Church-run media;
Opinion about the importance of the problem of pedophilia in the Catholic Church (follow-up);
• Opinions about several statements related to abuse cases in the Church (both first round and follow-up);
• Whether respondents searched for information on child abuse cases (follow-up);
• Whether respondents heard about sexual abuse cases by the Church in their environment (follow-up);
• Opinion about whether victims of abuse as a child in the past should speak out (follow-up).
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.