Trust in the State and Citizen Cooperation: Evidence from Pakistan

How to cite

Shaukat, Mahvish; Stegmann, Andreas; Nasim, Sanval; Khan, Adnan. 2020. "Trust in the State and Citizen Cooperation: Evidence from Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005744. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5744-1.2000000000000002

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mahvish Shaukat* , Andreas Stegmann , Sanval Nasim , Adnan Khan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005744
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5744-1.2000000000000002
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-04-27 – 2020-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O12, D7, D9, H75, I12
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5744

Abstract

Citizens’ willingness to cooperate with the state is a fundamental determinant of state capacity. This willingness to cooperate is particularly important in the context of pandemics: reducing the spread of a virus requires citizens to follow state directives and engage in behavioral change (e.g. social distancing, reporting symptoms, etc.). In many developing countries, however, states have limited capacity to even temporarily change the behavior of citizens. In this project, we investigate whether sharing information designed to increase trust in the state can improve citizen compliance with state directives on minimizing the spread of COVID-19. We test this in major urban centers in Punjab, Pakistan through three information treatments that emphasize one of the following: past state effectiveness in addressing a public health emergency, the importance of citizen cooperation in addressing a past public health emergency, and religious authorities' support for state directives. We will track citizen intentions, beliefs, perceived norms, and self-reported behaviors over time to understand how citizen trust in government and state institutions can foster cooperation with the state.

Experimental design

The study is a randomized controlled trial implemented in Punjab, Pakistan. The key hypothesis is that citizen compliance with state directives on reducing the spread of COVID-19 will depend on whether citizens trust the state, and believe it to be acting in their own interests. Where trust and perceived benevolence are high, citizens will be more likely to follow the state’s recommendations, thereby raising state capacity to address the crisis.

This evaluation tests this hypothesis by sharing information designed to increase citizen trust, perceived state benevolence, and citizen compliance with the state’s directives. All citizens in the study sample will receive basic information on the state's directives on reducing the spread of coronavirus. Citizens assigned to treatment groups will receive an additional message encouraging compliance with the state’s directives.

1. Basic information (control): Citizens will receive (i) basic information about the coronavirus; and (ii) the Punjab provincial government’s recommended response (e.g. handwashing, social distancing, etc.).

2. ... plus appeal to past state effectiveness: Citizens may be more willing to cooperate with the state after receiving positive information about the state’s ability to address crises in the past. In this treatment arm, citizens will receive a reminder of the Punjab provincial government’s success in addressing dengue outbreaks.

3. ... plus appeal to citizen cooperation in achieving past state effectiveness: Citizens may be more willing to cooperate with the state after receiving information about the role of citizens in enabling state successes in the past. Similar to the treatment above, citizens in this treatment arm will receive a reminder of the Punjab provincial government’s success in addressing dengue outbreaks - but with an emphasis on how citizen cooperation contributed to this success.

4. ... plus appeal to religious authority: Citizens may be more willing to respond to non-state actors such as religious authorities, rather than the government – especially when they perceive the state is encroaching on their religious rights. In this treatment arm, citizens will receive information on religious authorities support for the provincial government’s directives.

5. ... plus experimenter demand: To measure and net out experimenter demand effects, citizens in this treatment arm will receive basic information, along with a clearly stated opinion in favor of the provincial government and its recommendations.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
5000 individuals
Observations
5000 individuals
Arms
1000 individuals control; 1000 individuals past state effectiveness; 1000 individuals past state effectiveness + citizen cooperation, 1000 individuals religious authority; 1000 individuals experimenter demand.
Primary outcomes
Citizen attitudes towards government and state institutions (trust, perceived capacity, benevolence, etc.); self-reported behavior and intended behavior, perceived norms.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords