The goal of our project is to assess the effectiveness of an information campaign (as a type of a nudge) as well as monetary incentives to adhere to social distancing measures to prevent infection and further spread of COVID-19 in villages in rural Bangladesh.
We implement this project as a randomized controlled trial: villages are randomized into control and treatment villages based on their current situation with COVID-19. Overall, we plan to collect observations from more than 3000 participants from 150 villages. In each village, about 20-26 households will participate.
We plan two treatment interventions with randomly selected participants in the treatment villages. We measure health, knowledge and beliefs, and compliance with social distancing measures. In addition, partly from previous data collections with the households under study, but also from a new collection, we have a long list of preference and demographic measures to investigate heterogeneous responses of households in this epidemic.
Intervention
We have a single control group, and two treatment groups; and all villages in our household panel are divided into these groups (see Sections ‘Experimental Design’ and ‘Experiment Characteristics’ below for details).
Treatment households receive information and monetary incentives to adhere to social distancing measures and to prevent infection with the Coronavirus and further spread of COVID-19.
Experimental design
We have two treatments and a single control group, consisting of 45, 45, and 60 villages, respectively (for details, see section “Intervention” above).
Design details
Randomization method
For assignment of villages to treatment and control groups, we use the minMSE method by Schneider & Schlather (2020), which is a re-randomization method. Treatment assignment for villages was performed in an office on a computer using the ‘minMSE’ R package (Schneider & Baldini, 2019) with 1000 iterations and default parameters except for initial temperature (set at t0 = -10 for 10 percentage of initial value). The pre-treatment information considered for treatment assignment were collected in a village survey (see ‘Supporting Documents & Materials’ for details). We produced 1000 alternative treatment vectors to ensure treatment assignment was not deterministic, and selected one randomly. For assignment of individuals within treatment villages, we first built pairs of households that live close to each other, and then randomly assigned one to treatment and the other to the within-village control group using the ‘nbpMatching’ R package (Beck C, Lu B, Greevy R., 2015) following Lu et al. (2011).
Randomization unit
Two-step randomization: First, villages are assigned to treatment and control groups. Second, households within the treatment villages are selected randomly for treatment from our sample of households.
Clusters
We plan to use all 150 villages in our household panel.
Observations
On average, we plan to treat between 10 and 13 households per village, while further 10 to 13 households per village will serve as within village control households; we aim at the higher number for higher power, which, however, might not be feasible for capacity constraints as timely implementation and a short intervention period is of highest importance in this project. Thus, on average we address 20 to 26 households per village in 90 treatment villages, and 20 to 26 households in our 60 control villages. Our total sample size will thus consist of 3000 to 3900 households.
Arms
1. Information Treatment: 45 villages with 10-13 households (treated) and 10-13 households untreated: 900-1170 households
2. Information Treatment plus monetary incentive: 45 villages with 10-13 households (treated) and 10-13 households untreated: 900-1170 households
3. Control Treatment: 60 villages with 20-26 households: 1200-1560 households
Primary outcomes
In addition to primary outcomes gathered in two surveys, we aim to obtain mobile phone mobility data.
Mobile phone mobility data will be used on a daily basis, ideally from a point prior to the intervention, from the time of the intervention until two weeks after the intervention, and from the time of the intervention until three months after the intervention (or once the epidemic is over). However, at this point in time, we cannot be sure that the data we might obtain spans this time frame.
We consider the same primary outcomes from surveys at two points in time: The first collection will be two weeks after the intervention. The second collection will be three months after the intervention, or once the epidemic is over.
Primary outcomes will be collected from households in control villages, and from treated households in treatment villages, and additionally from their untreated neighbors in our sample. Moreover, a village survey might be conducted to inform about the situation in the village.
To assess success of our treatment and behavior of the treated households, we consider the following information: Knowledge and beliefs about the Coronavirus and COVID-19, compliance with preventative measures (e.g. social distancing) as collected by survey questions asked to households themselves and their neighbors, and as measured by mobile phone tracking.
To assess behavior of the untreated households (in treatment and control villages), we consider the following information: Knowledge and beliefs about COVID-19, compliance with preventative measures (e.g. social distancing) as collected by survey questions asked to households themselves and their neighbors, and as measured by mobile phone tracking.
To assess the overall situation of the pandemic in a household and a village, we consider the following information: Infections and symptoms, deaths.
Secondary outcomes
Higher Order Risk Preferences as measured by the method of Schneider, Ibanez and Riener (2020), using three certainty equivalents (for the normalized utilities of .25, .5, and .75) via the staircase method/bisection approach with 3 questions per certainty equivalent. Additionally, from previous data collection, we have measures on risk preferences, time preferences, and social preferences.
Sponsors
Name: Max Planck Institute for Research on Collective Goods, Bonn
Location: Germany
Url: https://coll.mpg.de
Partners
Name: Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf
Partner_type: none
Url: https://www.hhu.de
Name: The University of Sydney
Partner_type: none
Url: https://www.sydney.edu.au
Name: Evaluation and Consulting Services (ECONS) Ltd.
Partner_type: private_company
Url: https://google.de
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.