A Dynamic Investigation of Stereotypes, Belief Updating, and Behavior
How to cite
Coffman, Katherine; Araya, Paola Ugalde; Zafar, Basit. 2020. "A Dynamic Investigation of Stereotypes, Belief Updating, and Behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005712. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5712-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Many decisions (such as how much or what kind of education to get) are dynamic in nature, with individuals receiving feedback at one point in time and then making decisions much later. Zimmermann (2019) shows that individuals are less likely to recall negative feedback in the long run. Our project builds on this important work by asking whether there are gender differences in the propensity to incorporate positive and negative feedback in immediate and more long-term decision-making, and whether this gender difference depends upon the gender stereotype of the task. We also plan to explore the link between beliefs and choices about how to be compensated for performance, and whether the difficulty of the domain influences belief updating.
Experimental design
This is an online experiment consisting of two 30-minute sessions, completely approximately 1 week apart.
Session 1:
• Round 1 Performance: Individuals are asked to perform 2 tasks, one male-stereotypical (math) and one female-stereotypical (verbal). Each will be a multiple-choice quiz, calibrated so that quizzes from each domain are of similar difficulty on average across participants. There will be a “hard” treatment, where quizzes are designed to be more difficult on average, and an “easy” treatment, where quizzes are designed to be less difficult on average. Participants will be randomly assigned to one of the two treatments.
• Belief Elicitation and Provisional Choice for Round 2 Performance PRE-FEEDBACK: Using an incentivized procedure, we will next elicit beliefs about performance in each of the two Round 1 quizzes: guess of Round 1 score on each quiz and believed probability of having exactly that score. We will also ask them to assign probabilities to the likelihood of each possible rank relative to a fixed reference group of prior participants who have completed the same quiz (a group of 9 participants who participated before the real experiment started). We will also elicit the belief about being ranked in the top 40% relative to the fixed reference group.
At this stage, we will also introduce the choice about Round 2 performance (to be completed during Session 2). Participants will be informed that problems will be harder on average in Round 2. Participants will have the chance to choose how to be compensated for the quizzes performed in Round 2. Using multiple price lists, they will make a series of choices in which we will vary the incentives available to each task, some of which are competitive and some of which are piece-rate.
• Feedback Provision: Participants will then receive feedback about Round 1 performance. They will be told how their performance compared (better or worse) than one randomly chosen participant from the reference group for each Round 1 quiz.
• Belief Elicitation and Provisional Choice IMMEDIATELY POST-FEEDBACK: We will exactly repeat the belief elicitation and provisional choices for Round 2 compensation that participants completed pre-feedback. This stage will only be fielded to half the treatment participants.
Session 2:
• Belief Elicitation and Provisional Choice ONE WEEK POST-FEEDBACK: One week after the initial study, all participants will be re-invited. We will exactly repeat the belief elicitation and provisional choices for Round 2 performance that they completed pre-feedback.
• So, for some respondents we will have three provisional choices (pre-feedback; immediate post-feedback; one week post-feedback). For others we will have two provisional choices (pre-feedback; one week post-feedback). For each individual, one of these would be picked at random to count as their actual choice for Round 2 performance
• Round 2 Performance (performed one week post-feedback): We will implement the randomization to determine under which compensation scheme the participant will perform. However, we will first ask the participant to perform both tasks and only then inform them which task/incentive scheme was chosen for payment. That way, performance on both tasks would be under very similar informational conditions.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.