Publicity and Compliance in the Colombia Tutela
How to cite
Staton, Jeffrey; Gauri, Varun. 2015. "Publicity and Compliance in the Colombia Tutela." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000571. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.571-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Colombian tutela provides a swift mechanism for resolving state violations of individual rights. The Colombian Constitutional Court has provided innovative solutions through tutela to a variety of systemic bureaucratic failures, yet, the practical impact of these innovations depends on the ability of claimants to obtain through a court order what they could not get on their own, and that depends on compliance. Compliance is commonly monitored in legal systems via indirect monitoring, where litigants are themselves responsible for alerting judges to problems. Recently courts have begun directly monitoring compliance by tracking their own orders. We conduct a cluster randomized trial designed to evaluate the effect of direct compliance monitoring. Specifically, we consider the effect of increasing health provider expectations that the Colombian public will become aware of their activities on compliance with tutela orders governing health rights. Our hypothesis is that providers that expect public scrutiny of their behavior will experience better compliance outcomes than providers who do not.
Intervention
The aim of the treatment was to inform Empresas Promotoras de Salud (EPS), health maintenance organizations responsible for the delivery of health services in Colombia, that their compliance record with respect to orders in tutela cases was being tracked and that it would be publicized upon review. We informed treated EPS's that we were working in partnership with the Constitutional Court. Treatment involved a letter addressed to the President and Managing Directors of a selected EPS's, as well as follow up discussions with any EPS that reached out to our research team. The letter explained the purpose of the study, reviewed the results of our pilot study reporting the overall average compliance rates in the health sector, and a promise to publish the results of the study in July of 2014.
Experimental design
We conduct a cluster-randomized field experiment. There are 32 clusters, each cluster reflecting a single EPS. EPS's are blocked by the health care regime that they manage. EPS's that manage insured in the contributing regime (where individuals contribute to their premiums) constitute one block. The other block includes EPS's that manage insured in the subsidized regime (where premiums are paid for by the state). Fifteen EPS's managed insured exclusively in the subsidized regime. Eleven managed insured exclusively in the contributing regime. Five EPS's managed the care of individuals in both regimes and the regime for a single EPS was unclear. We randomly assign these six EPS's to the subsidized or contributing regime blocks. We then randomize treatment within each block.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.