A Field Experiment on Leveraging Intrinsic Motivation in Public Service Delivery
How to cite
Lee, Scott. 2014. "A Field Experiment on Leveraging Intrinsic Motivation in Public Service Delivery." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000568. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.568-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Although extrinsic and intrinsic motivation likely jointly explain the effort of many agents engaged in public service delivery, incentives typically only appeal to the former. In the context of a maternal health program in rural Uttar Pradesh, India, we develop a novel, mobile phone-based "intrinsic incentive" technology designed to increase health workers' intrinsic returns to effort. In a randomized field experiment, we test one version designed to have a larger effect on intrinsic utility against another designed to be less powerful. A one-year pilot experiment (March 2013 to February 2014) reveals the following findings. First, demand for both technologies is high; the average user accesses her software application approximately once every days for the duration of the one-year experiment. Second, average treatment effects are nil. Third, the high-powered intrinsic incentive is most effective when it leverages pre-existing intrinsic motivation; it produces a 38.4% increase in performance in the top tercile of intrinsically motivated workers. Finally, this effect appears to be mediated purely by making effort more intrinsically rewarding, and not by other mechanisms such as providing implicit extrinsic incentives.
Based on these hypothesis-generating findings, we conduct a replication experiment as an out-of-sample test in an adjoining population of health workers.
Intervention
We develop a novel mobile phone software application that is designed to act as an intrinsic incentive--an incentive that increases agents' intrinsic, and only intrinsic, returns to effort. We develop and test two intrinsic incentive interventions: one that is high-powered and another that is low-powered. Both are information services. The high-powered intrinsic incentive technology is a phone-based "self-tracking" tool that allows the health worker to graphically review her performance in a real-time manner. In contrast, the low-powered intrinsic incentive provides generic messages irrespective of the agent's effort. Concretely, it is a phone-based "advice and encouragement" tool that avails to the health worker messages about her job responsibilities as well as inspirational quotes.
Experimental design
Prior to the launch of the experimental interventions, a baseline survey will be conducted in which every health worker will be interviewed on a one-on-one basis. The baseline data will provide variables for stratified randomization.
We will randomly assign each health worker to one of the two intrinsic incentive treatments. The corresponding software will be installed on each health worker's phone, and the health workers within each treatment will be trained on the use of the software in batches. Trainings will be conducted at the implementing partner's project office in the administrative block's main town. All participants will be told that two different phone-based tools are being piloted.
Once the experiment is launched, care will be taken to preserve the economic intent of the intervention: to alter intrinsic returns to effort without altering real or perceived extrinsic returns to effort. In order to provide soft reminders of the software applications, a generic, automated SMS message will be sent to each health worker weekly. If participants report a malfunction of the phone or software, research staff will respond to the troubleshooting request in a demand-driven manner. Periodic (e.g., quarterly) checks may also be conducted to ensure that hardware and software are functioning correctly. Other than these interactions, there will be no regular monitoring or encouragement of use of the technologies. Midline and endline surveys may be conducted.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.