We perform two experiments to measure how government declarations and actions affect mental states and behavior. To manipulate the (true) information that participants receive, we will randomize exposure to news about government actions. We will then analyze how the nature of this information affects mental states and behavior.
Intervention
We run two separate experiments, with distinct samples, simultaneously. Both experiments manipulate exposure to information about the government.
Experimental design
We randomize (truthful) information about statements given and actions taken by the government.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization in Qualtrics
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
2,000 per experiment
Observations
2,000 per experiment
Arms
1,000
Primary outcomes
Anxiety measured via the Beck Anxiety Inventory, aggregated into one index
Update in predictions about how severe COVID-19 will be (log predicted number of deaths)
Demand for information
Performance on a data entry task
Willingness to pay as a measure of hoarding behavior
Heterogeneity by:
- Baseline Trump support (three groups: oppose trump, support trump, undecided)
- Baseline belief that the government has or acts on own information
- Baseline belief about severity of COVID-19 (predicted number of deaths, predicted death rate).
Additional primary outcomes for Strong vs. Weak:
- Update in predictions about how severe COVID-19 will be (death rate)
Additional primary outcomes for Steady vs. Changing:
- Update in support for Donald Trump
Secondary outcomes
Updates in perception of how the government is handling the crisis
Change in width of confidence intervals about predicting the number of deaths from coronavirus in the US
Update in predictions about the stock market
Change in self-reported uncertainty about the stock market
Anxiety decomposition
Risk aversion
An exploratory empirical strategy will use our treatments as instrumental variables for anxiety in order to explore the causal effects of anxiety on economic preferences as measured by the global preference survey and dictator game. Because the exclusion restriction seems imperfectly satisfied, this approach will be secondary
The number of self-reported people the person plans to meet with outside the household
Heterogeneity by the same sources as in primary outcomes:
- Baseline Trump support (three groups: oppose Trump, support Trump, undecided)
- Baseline belief that the government has or acts on own information
- Baseline belief about severity of COVID-19 (predicted number of deaths, predicted death rate)
Additional heterogeneity of primary and secondary outcomes by the baseline amount of news the participant has consumed about COVID-19.
Additional secondary outcomes for Strong vs. Weak:
- Update in support for Donald Trump and the government
Additional secondary outcomes for Steady vs. Changing:
- Update in predictions about how severe COVID-19 will be (death rate)
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.