Coronavirus (COVID-19) Small Business Government Relief Takeup Project

How to cite

Neilson, Christopher; Ulyssea, Gabriel; Humphries, John Eric. 2020. "Coronavirus (COVID-19) Small Business Government Relief Takeup Project." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005626. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5626-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christopher Neilson* , Gabriel Ulyssea , John Eric Humphries

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005626
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5626-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-03-27 – 2020-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5626

Abstract

Many small businesses have already been deeply affected by the COVID-19 crisis, leading them to lay off employees, temporarily close shop, or go out of business completely. In response, governments have passed specific provisions to help support small businesses as part of large aid packages. However, we document in a baseline survey that many small businesses may not understand who is eligible for aid, what aid is available or how to apply. This project evaluates the roles of information frictions on small businesses’ utilization of newly available government assistance. To begin, we survey small businesses in the United States and Latin America about how they have been affected by the COVID-19 crisis. Next in the first round of the pilot outreach program, we randomly assign small businesses from eight Latin American countries to informational interventions with different levels of intensity. Businesses will then be followed up to see if they successfully applied for aid, and how the aid affected expectations, layoffs and probability of going out of business. Using the experimental design, we will study the role of information frictions on differences in applying for aid by firm size, and how that aid affects business survival. The more effective measures will then be scaled up if any are found to be cost-effective.

Intervention

We survey small businesses in Latin America about how they have been affected by the COVID-19 crisis. Next, we randomly assign small businesses to different informational interventions with different levels of intensity. Businesses will then be followed up to see if they successfully applied for aid, and how the aid affected owner's expectations, layoffs and probability of going out of business. Using the experimental design, we will study the role of information frictions on differences in applying for aid by firm size, and how that aid affects business survival. The more effective measures will then be scaled up in a second round if any are found to be cost-effective.

Experimental design

Small businesses are recruited through social media to take our baseline survey conducted in Qualtrics. Those who share contact information with us are included in the experiment sample. Firms are randomly assigned to the "low-intensity" information intervention group, or to the "high-intensity" information intervention group. In Mexico, there is also a "medium-intensity" information intervention group. Randomization is stratified by country and date of response.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done by a computer. It was stratified by country and date of response. For firms in Mexico, we further stratified by State, as there was substantial variation in policies across states.
Randomization unit
The firm
Clusters
To assess the impact of T2 vs. T1 the sample size is 10,895 firms (Sample 1). To assess the impact of T3 vs. T1 the sample size is 2,804 firms (Sample 2). Finally, with the 3,334 firms from Mexico (Sample 3) we can test both T4 vs. T1, and T4 vs. T2. As per our intervention description, a group of Mexican firms belong to both Sample 1 and Sample 3. Overall, there are 15,367 firms in our experiment sample. More details can be found in the Pre Analysis Plan
Observations
To assess the impact of T2 vs. T1 the sample size is 10,895 firms (Sample 1). To assess the impact of T3 vs. T1 the sample size is 2,804 firms (Sample 2). Finally, with the 3,334 firms from Mexico (Sample 3) we can test both T4 vs. T1, and T4 vs. T2. As per our intervention description, a group of Mexican firms belong to both Sample 1 and Sample 3. Overall, there are 15,367 firms in our experiment sample. More details can be found in the Pre Analysis Plan
Arms
Email (T1): 8,921 firms Email + Phone session + Chatbot (T2): 3,252 firms Email + Phone session (T3): 1,526 firms Email + Chatbot (T4, only in Mexico): 1,668 firms
Primary outcomes
1. Firm survival, 2. Number of layoffs
Secondary outcomes
1. Awareness about government relief policies, Take up of government aid (2. Whether the firm applied for aid, 3. Whether the firm got aid), 4. Expectations of the owner about recovery

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords