Motivating Banking Agents to Increase Transactions at Scale - Experimental Evidence from India
How to cite
Nagpal, Karan; Butcher, Luke; Parrado, Andrés. 2020. "Motivating Banking Agents to Increase Transactions at Scale - Experimental Evidence from India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005625. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5625-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While India has made substantial progress towards financial inclusion, much remains to be done to ensure everyone utilizes, and benefits from, increased access to the formal financial system. In particular, despite increases in bank account ownership, account usage remains low. This problem is especially pronounced in rural and semi-urban areas, where few bank branches operate. India has responded by promoting "Cash-in, Cash-out" banking agents.
This trial tests whether a composite intervention focusing on banking agents increases account usage at scale. The agents in this study belong to a single banking agent network company, and they work across Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. The intervention consists primarily of providing savings calendars to the agents to provide to their customers. These agents are also trained to explain the calendar to customers, to encourage customer savings, and to track distribution of the calendars. Thirdly, agents receive SMS messages that remind them about the content of the training. Finally, managers who supervise these agents receive similar training and SMS reminders. We randomized a sample of 794 agents across treatment and control, with 402 agents assigned to the treatment group and 392 to the control. In the aggregate, we distributed a total of 64,000 calendars to the treatment agents, who were asked to distribute at least half the calendars to women customers. We will evaluate the impact of this intervention on deposits, net deposits (deposits minus withdrawals), and transactions at the level of the banking agents, at both 7 weeks (when India's lockdown to combat COVID-19 began) and three months after training.
Experimental design
The sample of 794 agents in this study, spread across Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, were randomized into two groups: treatment (402) and control (392). Treatment agents received a composite intervention consisting of the following: savings calendars for customers, training on savings mobilization, and SMS messages. The managers of agents received similar training and similar SMS messages.
More specifically, in order to distribute the calendars, we conducted a total of 10 training sessions for the banking agents. Each session was attended by anywhere between 14 and 60 agents. These sessions were accompanied by sessions of the implementing partner on operating banking software (The control agents did not receive this additional training). The savings calendar session focused on three components:
1. The team explained every component of the savings calendars to agents and their managers and highlighted the importance of the calendars as an avenue to build better customer relationships.
2. The team provided advice to agents and their managers on addressing the aforementioned behavioral barriers to saving that customers often face. Agents were asked to communicate to customers the importance of saving for achieving their personal goals, the security benefits of saving with the agent, and the fact that customers should deposit even small amounts into their accounts. These three recommendations were also printed on a savings encouragement sheet that was distributed to the agents.
3. The team also explained the process for monitoring the distribution of the calendars. We provided a distribution sheet to the banking agents to document which customers received calendars. Agents had to send a copy of this sheet twice a week to their managers, who would collate them for the research team.
Following the training, each agent received their set of calendars, the savings encouragement sheet, and the calendar distribution sheet. Agents at and above the median for average number of unique customers per month (based on five pre-intervention months) received 240 calendars, while those below the median received 80. 77% of agents completed the in-person training session. Sub-K separately trained and delivered materials to agents who did not complete the training session. Moreover, in the time between randomization and training,
6 agents assigned to treatment stopped working as agents, lowering the number to be trained from 402 to 396. As of 1 April, monitoring data from 82% of these 396 agents reached the research team. Agents reported distributing 39,180 of 64,000 calendars (61%).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.