The effects of informing tax payers about individual taxes and government expenditure on transparency perception, trust in the government, tax compliance and voting behavior

How to cite

Cooper, Ryan; Sanhueza, Antonia; Obach, Juan; Fernandez, Nicolás; Castellón, Pamela; Carreño, Alvaro M.; Gadenne, Lucie. 2020. "The effects of informing tax payers about individual taxes and government expenditure on transparency perception, trust in the government, tax compliance and voting behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005593. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5593-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ryan Cooper* , Antonia Sanhueza , Juan Obach , Nicolás Fernandez , Pamela Castellón , Alvaro M. Carreño , Lucie Gadenne

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0005593
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5593-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2020-04-20 – 2020-12-15
Countries
Chile ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/5593

Abstract

This trial will investigate the potential effects of an information campaign providing individual information on tax payment, government national expenditure (what expenditure areas (education, health, etc.) is tax money spent on) and on national and regional use of government funds (what concrete policies the government spends on) to a large sample of chilean tax payers. A final treatment consists in allowing taxpayers to provide feedback to government regarding how taxpayer resources should be spent by the government. Using a randomized controlled trial, we will evaluate the impact of these different treatments in order to asses which one is most effective to increase government transparency perception and trust in the government. Finally, we will test the effects of these interventions on peoples actual behavior: tax compliance and voting participation.

Intervention

The intervention consists in an information campaign to tax payers on individual tax payment and government expenditure. The trail will test four different treatments that combine into six experimental arms.

Treatments:
Treatment 1: Tax information + expenditure distribution. People are reminded how much they pay individually in VAT and income tax. They are also informed how the tax money they contribute to the government is spent. The expenditure information is provided graphically, showing different categories of expenditure.
Treatment 2: Tax information + national use of government expenditure. Instead of being informed on the distribution of expenditure, people are shown a variety of concrete policies the government has spent tax resources on.
Treatment 3: Tax information + regional use of government expenditure. This treatment is the same as treatment 2, only that it provides regional as opposed to national information on use of tax resources.
Treatment 4: Tax payer feedback to government. People are given the opportunity to provide feedback to the government, regarding what they think the government should spend money on. This treatment is added to treatment one, two and three for half of the treated sample.

Experimental Arm:
Arm 1: Treatment 1
Arm 2: Treatment 2
Arm 3: Treatment 3
Arm 4: Treatment 1 + 4
Arm 5: Treatment 2 + 4
Arm 6: Treatment 3 + 4
Control Group

Experimental design

The six experimental arms previously described and a control group will be compared statistically in order to measure causal effects on outcomes of interest.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization done in an office by a computer. We will use the stata command randtreat and stratify by previos income, tax status (people that must pay taxes and those that do not need to pay taxes this year) and tax risk categories (tax service estimation of tax payers risk to not comply with tax duty).
Randomization unit
Individual randomization.
Clusters
Individual randomization. No Clusters.
Observations
160,000 tax payers.
Arms
Arm 1: 10.000 tax payers. Arm 2: 10.000 tax payers. Arm 3: 10.000 tax payers. Arm 4: 10.000 tax payers. Arm 5: 10.000 tax payers. Arm 6: 10.000 tax payers. Control: 100.000 tax payers.
Primary outcomes
Perception of Transparency and Trust in the Government
Secondary outcomes
Tax Compliance, Voting Participation

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords