Expectations and Choice: Evidence from a Home Upgrading Program
How to cite
Gine, Xavier; Medina, Elianny; Melo, Virginia; Giné, Xavier. 2020. "Expectations and Choice: Evidence from a Home Upgrading Program." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005580. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5580-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Expectations about the benefits of a social program, and the degree of engagement in its implementation can drastically change the perceived gains from it. Higher than realized expectations can lead to disappointment and even refusal of the program, while the possibility of choosing aspects of its implementation can increase satisfaction. We use a 2x2 randomized design that explores the expansion of a home upgrading program in the Dominican Republic to study the degree to which unmet expectations and choice over the implementation affect satisfaction and well-being of beneficiaries.
Intervention
In this project we evaluate an existing national program that upgrades the homes of beneficiaries of Progresando con Solidaridad (ProSoli), the conditional cash transfer (CCT) program of the Dominican Republic government. The home improvements include upgrading dirt (and badly damaged cement) floors into new cement floors, as well as painting the exterior walls of the house. Beneficiary families of the program receive a letter that describes the home improvements in general terms. We combine 2 interventions, as follows:
Message specificity
When announcing the program to selected beneficiaries, we provide a detailed description of the home improvements to half of the household beneficiaries ('specific message'), while the remaining treated households are given the status-quo general letter ('general message').
Choice of color:
Half of the treated households in our study are allowed to choose the color that will be used to paint the exterior walls of their homes ('color choice'), while the remaining treated households are not given such choice ('no color choice').
Experimental design
The two interventions are combined in a 2x2 design, with four treatment and a control group. We group households in clusters, that is, small geographical areas each consisting of 3 to 4 households. Clusters are assigned to one of the four treatment or control group: 10% of the clusters are assigned to the 'control group', where all households in the cluster do not receive the program. The remaining 90% of clusters are divided evenly into the four treatment groups. To assess spillover effects, 20% of households in treated clusters will not be targeted and thus will not receive the program. By design they are located close to the "targeted" households that will receive the program. The experiment thus consists of the following groups of households: (i) control households, (ii) untargeted households, and households that receive (iii) general message and no color choice, (iv) general message and color choice, (v) specific message and no color choice, and (vi) specific message and color choice.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.