The willingness to pay for urban amenities
How to cite
Brüll, Eduard; Arntz, Melanie; Lipowski, Cäcilia. 2020. "The willingness to pay for urban amenities." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0005574. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.5574-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Attracting high-skilled individuals is one of the most important aspects of cities' regional development strategies. While some policies aim at attracting firms to increase the local demand for high-skilled labour, others aim to directly raise high-skilled labour supply by attracting high skilled individuals with better local amenities. Empirically, cities with better cultural offerings or greater perceived openness indeed tend to have a higher share of high-skilled people. However, the effectiveness of these policies that are focused on amenities are hotly debated, as it is not clear whether people follow amenities or amenities follow people.
Therefore we use a stated-preference choice experiment to study how individuals value local amenities in their relocation decisions between different cities. In this experiment, we pose a variety of randomized choices between job offers in two hypothetical cities to a representative sample of the German working population. Each of the choice scenario consists of two alternatives specifying a combination of earnings and the quality of different amenities. Our main focus in the analysis of these choices will be on the respondents' willingness to forego higher wages for better local amenities: Which amenities are more relevant for the relocation choice? Does the measured implicit willingness to pay for different types of urban amenities vary between different groups of respondents? Are preferences different between high-skilled and less-skilled individuals?
Experimental design
Our experiment is a discrete choice experiment in a representative offline sampled online panel of the German population (Payback Panel). Each survey participant is presented with seven randomly selected scenarios from a series of 6435 possible scenarios, where he or she has to choose from two job offers in hypothetical cities. These scenarios differ in 7 attributes that can have three possible levels each. The first attribute is the hypothetical income of the respondents, which can be either the last monthly wage or an increase of 5% or 10%, depending on the scenario. The other six attributes are measures for the quality of different urban amenities and can take three different levels ("low quality", "medium quality" and "high quality"). These individual amenities are cultural offerings, social diversity, ecological quality, quality of the infrastructure, economic dynamism and family friendliness of a city.
Our design of the choice scenarios is based on a resolution 4 orthogonal array (L243.3.20) of the possible attribute combinations, which contains 243 alternatives. We choose this design array as a starting point so that we can estimate the effect of two-level interactions of attributes. If all possible unique combinations of the 243 alternatives are considered, there would be 29,403 possible decision scenarios.
However we impose three different restrictions on the design. First, given that 6 of our attributes are either the respondents wage or a public amenity that has a clear quality ordering, we exclude strictly dominated choices from the set of decision scenarios. Second, for scenarios, where the wage is equal in both alternatives, we only keep the ones where this is the last monthly wage. Third, to reduce the cognitive load of the scenarios we only retain choices where a maximum of 3-4 factors are different in the two alternatives.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Melanie Arntz, Eduard Brüll, Cäcilia Lipowski, Do preferences for urban amenities differ by skill?, Journal of Economic Geography, Volume 23, Issue 3, May 2023, Pages 541–576, https://doi.org/10.1093/jeg/lbac025 https://academic.oup.com/joeg/article/23/3/541/6696183
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.